in

15 Most Popular Papa Murphy’s Pizzas and More

Try the best food at Papa Murphy’s with our list of favorites

Papa Murphy’s has elevated take-home pizzas to gourmet meals made with high-quality ingredients. My favorite thing about Papa Murphy’s take n’ bake pizzas? They make virtually no mess and take less than 20 minutes to cook. 

Take Home Pizza from Papa Murphy's

Papa Murphy’s was founded in 1995 and has grown to be the fifth-largest pizza chain in the United States.

The best Papa Murphy’s menu items are their take n’ bake pizzas. Every time I order Papa Murphy’s, I am blown away by the high-quality ingredients, easy preparation, and low cost. 

Pizza dough is prepped daily in-house at over 1,300 locations throughout North America. Customers simply walk in, order from the menu, or customize their pizza toppings to their taste. Next, bring the uncooked pizza home to bake whenever is most convenient for you. 

With premium ingredients like Canadian bacon, 100% whole-milk mozzarella cheese, and made-from-scratch desserts, you will be hard-pressed to find a Papa Murphy’s menu item you do not like. 

Best Food on Papa Murphy’s Menu

Check out the top 15 best Papa Murphy’s menu items below. 

Cowboy Pizza

The Cowboy Pizza from Papa Murphy’s was the first menu item that I ever tried and it has kept me coming back ever since.

The combination of salty from the olives mixes with the creaminess of the cheese which compliments the spices in the pepperoni and sausage pieces. 

The Cowboy Pizza is covered in traditional red sauce, 100% whole-milk mozzarella cheese, pepperoni slices, sausage bits, thinly sliced mushrooms, and black olives. Then it is sprinkled with cheddar cheese and the Papa Murphy’s herb and cheese seasoning.

All of these delicious ingredients come on the original Papa Muprhy’s crust handmade every morning. 


Garden Veggie Pizza

The Garden Veggie Pizza is one of the best Papa Murphy’s menu items for vegetarians.

I find that the creamy white sauce is a delicious switch from the traditional red sauce while the heaps of vegetables on this pizza give me feel-good vibes. 

The Garden Veggie Pizza has a base of Papa Murphy’s original crust and gourmet white sauce. Toppings on this pizza include whole-milk mozzarella cheese, mild cheddar cheese, artichoke hearts, Roma tomatoes, zucchini, sliced mushrooms, spinach, yellow, green, and red peppers. 

This pie is finished off with a sprinkle of herb and cheese seasoning for that traditional Papa Murphy’s flavor.  


Hawaiian Pizza

The Hawaiian Pizza is one of the best Papa Murphy’s menu items to order for parties.

I always grab a few Papa Murphy’s options and find that this Hawaiian Pizza is a major hit or group discussion starter. 

This gourmet Hawaiian pizza comes on the Papa Murphy’s original crust with traditional red sauce and is topped with freshly shredded mozzarella cheese, crispy Canadian bacon bits, and Dole pineapple slices. 

I recommend customizing the traditional Hawaiian pizza with Papa Murphy’s creamy garlic sauce, instead of the traditional red sauce, for a more decadent take on a well-known pizza flavor. 


5 Meat Pizza

The 5 Meat Pizza is one of my favorite stuffed pizzas at Papa Murphy’s.

A stuffed pizza is a double-layer pizza and the 5 Meat Pizza is a double-decker carnivore’s dream dish. 

The first layer of the Papa Murphy’s 5 Meat Pizza has red sauce, Canadian bacon bits, 100% whole-milk mozzarella cheese, pepperoni slices, and sausage chunks. The second layer is doused in red sauce, ground beef, and more cheese. 

The 5 meat pizza is one of the best Papa Murphy’s menu items for the meat lovers of your family or friend group. 


Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

The Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza is a new menu item from Papa Murphy’s that combines two beloved foods into one: the cheeseburger and the pizza. 

The bacon cheeseburger pizza has a base of Original Papa Murphy’s crust topped with a combination of ketchup and mustard called Burger Sauce.

On top of the Burger Sauce is freshly shredded 100% whole-milk Mozzarella cheese, ground beef, crispy bacon pieces, gooey Roma tomatoes, and fresh onions. 

The final touch? A layer of tangy dill-pickle chips that has my mouth salivating just remembering it.

The Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza is one of the best Papa Murphy’s menu items for those who never know what to order. 


Gourmet Vegetarian Pizza

Start Meatless Mondays off on the right foot with Papa Murphy’s Gourmet Vegetarian Pizza. 

The Gourmet Vegetarian Pizza is another one of the best Papa Murphy’s menu items for vegetarians. 

I love that the Gourmet Vegetarian Pizza uses an artisan thin crust with Papa Murphy’s creamy garlic sauce. Each bite has that perfect ratio of crunch to sauciness and is loaded with veggies. 

The Gourmet Vegetarian Pizza has 100% whole-milk mozzarella cheese, spinach, zucchini, sliced mushrooms, artichoke hearts, tomatoes, onions, and Papa Murphy’s herb and cheese seasoning. 

Just pop this pizza in the oven for twelve to eighteen minutes and impress your vegetarian friends.


Herb Chicken Mediterranean Pizza

The Herb Chicken Mediterranean Pizza is one of the best Papa Murphy’s menu items for the summertime.

I love putting this pizza in the barbecue to give it a nice smokey flavor for patio dinners. 

The Herb Chicken Mediterranean Pizza has olive oil and garlic sauce on an artisan thin crust. This focaccia-like pizza has flavorful herbed chicken pieces, sun-dried tomatoes, spinach, zesty herbs, and feta cheese.

It has a delicious salty flavor from the feta that pairs with the sweetness of the sun-dried tomatoes.

The Herb Chicken Mediterranean Pizza is great served with balsamic vinegar or crushed red pepper flakes. 


Italian Salad

The Italian Salad is my go-to salad option when I order from Papa Murphy’s.

I always prefer to include something green on my plate and this Papa Murphy salad makes it easy to get my veggies in.

It is a simple romaine lettuce base but comes topped with cheddar and mozzarella cheese, Roma tomatoes, premium pepperoni slices, and salty black olives for a complex array of flavors. 

Choose your favorite dressing from home or pair it with Papa Murphy’s low-calorie Italian salad dressing.

I like to pair the Italian Salad with the Herb Chicken Mediterranean Pizza because I take pieces of chicken from the pizza and pop them into my salad. 


S’mores Dessert Pizza

Who can say no to dessert when it is a S’mores Dessert Pizza?

Papa Murphy’s S’mores Dessert Pizza is entirely made from scratch and features a pizza crust base filled with cookie dough, chocolate chips, marshmallows, and crunchy crispy toppings.

It is a decadent dessert made for sharing with friends or family. 

My favorite part about the S’mores Dessert Pizzas from Papa Murphy’s is that the entire house smells like cookie dough and chocolate as it is baking and as it is out cooling.

This is by far the best Papa Murphy’s menu item for movie nights, living room camp nights, or girl’s nights.  


Chocolate Chip Cookie

Enjoy the simple things in life with Papa Murphy’s Chocolate Chips Cookies.

This ready-made chocolate chip cookie dough makes cookie-making mess-free. Simply put them on a tray in your preheated oven and let them turn your kitchen into a sweet-smelling paradise. 

Once cooked, Papa Murphy’s Chocolate Chips Cookies are perfectly crunchy on the outside and gooey on the inside. The dough is freshly made in-house with semi-sweet chocolate chips. 

This is one of the best Papa Murphy’s menu items to order with kids since they get to watch the cookies bake without making a mess of the kitchen. 


All Meat Crustless Keto Pizza

Papa Murphy’s has a specialized menu for ketogenic dieters featuring low-carb crustless pizzas like the must-try All-Meat Crustless Keto Pizza.

Opt for the creamy garlic sauce or olive oil and garlic sauce and this is one of the best Papa Murphy’s menu items for keto dieters 

Choose from Papa Murphy’s traditional red sauce, creamy garlic sauce, or olive oil and garlic sauce as your topping.

This pizza is loaded with 100% whole-milk mozzarella cheese, premium pepperoni, Canadian bacon, salami slices, Italian sausage, and ground beef. 

The All-Meat Crustless Keto Pizza meets your protein macros without sacrificing flavor or your carb intake.


Chicken Garlic Pizza

The Chicken Garlic Pizza is savory and creamy.

Veer away from the traditional pepperoni and cheese because this pizza is one of the best Papa Murphy’s menu items for trying something different. 

The Chicken Garlic Pizza has a base of Papa Murphy’s original crust topped with creamy garlic sauce and antibiotic-free grilled chicken.

For more creaminess, 100% whole-milk mozzarella and mild cheddar cheeses are layered on top. Then this pizza is topped with Roma tomatoes, green onions, and herb and cheese seasoning. 

The garlic sauce mixed with the creamy mozzarella will have you going back in for a second slice. 


Cowboy Crustless Keto Pizza

The Cowboy Crustless Keto Pizza is another ketogenic-friendly Papa Murphy’s menu item worth trying with your next order.

This keto-friendly pizza has similar ingredients to the original Cowboy Pizza, but with fewer carbs. 

The Cowboy Crustless Keto Pizza comes with a choice of red sauce, creamy garlic sauce, or olive oil and garlic sauce.

On top is 100% whole-milk mozzarella cheese, mild cheddar cheese, premium pepperoni, Italian sausage, sliced mushrooms, black olives, and Papa Murphy’s herb and cheese blend without the crust. 

The Cowboy Crustless Keto Pizza is a great take n’ bake pizza to have handy if you have friends or family following the keto diet. It can be hard to prepare for dietary restrictions, but this quick and delicious option will keep you from sweating. 


Big Murphy Stuffed Pizza

The Big Murphy Stuffed Pizza is a delicious double-decker pizza.

I like to bring these out during sports games or on rainy afternoons while watching a movie. 

The first layer features Papa Murphy’s traditional red sauce, 100% whole-milk mozzarella cheese, premium pepperoni slices, Italian sausage, sliced mushrooms, and black olives. 

The second pizza layer features traditional red sauce, green peppers, Roma tomatoes, mozzarella, and cheddar cheese with the Papa Murphy’s herb and cheese seasoning blend. 

Pair this with one of Papa Murphy’s salads and desserts and you have yourself a full-course meal. 


Chicken Bacon Artichoke Pizza

The Chicken Bacon Artichoke Pizza is one of my all-time favorite Papa Murphy’s menu items, especially when I want something light.

The thin crust is crunchy, while the zesty spices leave a delicious aftertaste. 

The Chicken Bacon Artichoke Pizza has an artisan thin crust base with a creamy garlic sauce. On top are zesty herbs, parmesan cheese, chicken, spinach, artichoke hearts, and bacon. 

This is one of the best Papa Murphy’s menu items to pair with other finger foods on a wine and cheese night. 


Best Papa Murphy’s Menu Items

  1. Cowboy Pizza
  2. Garden Veggie Pizza
  3. Hawaiian Pizza
  4. 5 Meat pizza
  5. Bacon Cheeseburger
  6. Gourmet Vegetarian Pizza
  7. Herb Chicken Mediterranean Pizza
  8. Italian Salad
  9. S’mores Dessert Pizza
  10. Chocolate Chip Cookie
  11. All Meat Crustless Keto Pizza
  12. Chicken Garlic Pizza
  13. Cowboy Crustless Keto Pizza
  14. Big Murphy Stuffed Pizza
  15. Chicken Bacon Artichoke Pizza

Final Thoughts

It is hard to find a Papa Murphy’s pizza, dessert, or salad that is not well-priced and delicious. The best Papa Murphy’s menu items consist of abundant ingredients with flavors thoughtfully balanced in each bite.

From the Herb Chicken Mediterranean Pizza to the Garden Veggie Pizza to crustless Keto pizzas, there are tasty options for everyone. 

It is no wonder that Papa Murphy’s has risen to be one of the top five most purchased pizza chains. Papa Murphy’s take n’ bake pizzas cook in less time than it takes for the delivery person to get to your door for a fraction of the cost.

Customers at Papa Murphy’s consistently rate the service, prices, and taste of Papa Murphy’s highly. 

This page may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we'll earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Written by Erin B.

Erin lives in East Passyunk and enjoys checking out the local restaurants in South Philly and beyond. Her favorite restaurants are those with spicy food and outdoor seating so that she can bring along her dog, Miss Piggy.