16 Most Popular Pizza Topping to Order

Can you imagine a world without pizza? Neither can we. Universally adored, this perfect blend of crispy crust, tangy sauce, gooey cheese, and various toppings tantalizes taste buds worldwide. But when it comes to pizza toppings, we often find ourselves in the heart of a delicious controversy – what is the best pizza topping?

Is it the classic simplicity of the Margherita? The exotic flavor of BBQ chicken? The savory sensation of pepperoni? Or the unexpected delight of the controversial pineapple on a Hawaiian pizza? As varied and distinct as the individuals who enjoy them, pizza toppings reflect personal palate and culinary curiosity.

In this blog post, we’re on a quest to dive deep into the crust of this debate, leaving no stone unturned in the pursuit of the ultimate topping. We’ll explore various toppings’ origins, popularity, and unique taste profiles and why they incite such passion among pizza lovers.

Whether you’re a dedicated meat lover, a devout veggie enthusiast, or an adventurous flavor explorer, prepare for a journey through a world where anything can be a pizza topping, and only one can claim the crown of the best. Let’s slice into it!

---

Pepperoni

When it comes to pizza toppings, pepperoni stands tall as a perennial favorite, garnering accolades from around the globe.

From New York City to Naples, the ruby-red slices of this subtly spicy sausage reign supreme in popularity. Pepperoni’s appeal lies in its ability to elevate the humble pizza with its unique texture, flavor, and visual appeal.

As the pizza heats up in the oven, the thin slices of pepperoni curl and crisp, the oils sizzling and releasing an irresistible aroma. Its spicy kick complements the smooth, melted cheese, and its rich, smoky taste enhances the tanginess of the tomato sauce.

But pepperoni’s charm isn’t just in its flavor – those beautifully scattered ruffled red rounds also give the pizza a visually inviting finish.

Despite the influx of innovative and unconventional toppings, pepperoni remains an indomitable stalwart, its position on top seemingly unshakeable in its savory supremacy. Its presence turns a simple pizza into an iconic dish, representing the classic, comfort-filled experience many pizza lovers crave.

---

Sausage

Continuing with meat themes, we have sausage.

Sausage, a humble yet delightful pizza topping, invites you to explore the layers of its exquisite depth and complexity.

Its appeal is universal, satisfying the taste buds of countless pizza enthusiasts, from Chicago’s deep-dish lovers to those favoring thin-crust Neapolitan styles. Each morsel of sausage is a flavor bomb, encompassing a myriad of spices that explode in a symphony of savory goodness with each bite.

Depending on the type, it could offer a mild sweetness, a smoky undertone, or a fiery kick, providing an element of surprise to your pizza-eating experience. As it cooks, the sausage crumbles merge with the melting cheese, its juices seeping into the sauce, enriching it with a robust, meaty, comforting, and indulgent flavor.

The texture, too, is part of the joy. The slight resistance of the sausage, followed by the juiciness, makes every bite genuinely satisfying. It’s a topping that not only enhances the overall flavor profile of a pizza but also lends it a strong character, making your pizza experience all the more fulfilling.

---

Mushrooms

Mushrooms, the unsung heroes of the pizza topping world, bring an understated elegance to every slice they grace.

Hugely popular among vegetarians and carnivores alike, their delicate yet distinctive flavor imparts a unique, earthy charm to the vibrant symphony of pizza flavors. Mushrooms possess a remarkable ability to absorb and enhance the flavors around them, soaking in the zesty tomato sauce and creamy cheese and offering a textural contrast that is both tender and satisfying.

When exposed to the high heat of a pizza oven, they release their natural juices, giving a layer of moistness to the pizza that is both surprising and delightful. And let’s remember the varieties! From the common button mushroom to the fancier cremini and shiitake, each brings its flavor profile to the table, adding an element of culinary sophistication to your humble pizza.

Whether enjoying a simple mushroom and cheese pizza or an elaborate gourmet creation, the humble mushroom topping brings a touch of earthy umami that takes your pizza experience from delightful to unforgettable.

---

Bacon

Bacon, that irresistible embodiment of smoky, savory decadence, has secured its place in the hearts of pizza lovers worldwide. As a pizza topping, it’s a game changer.

Whether indulging in a classic bacon and cheese pizza or sampling an innovative, gourmet combination, bacon can uplift the pizza experience to new, compelling heights. Each bite of bacon delivers a satisfying crunch, followed by an indulgent melt-in-your-mouth sensation.

Its rich, smoky flavor provides a beautiful counterbalance to the tangy tomato sauce, while its natural saltiness enhances the creamy, melty cheese. As it cooks, the rendered fat from the bacon seeps into the pizza, infusing every element with its distinctive, intoxicating flavor.

But it’s not just the taste that’s appealing – seeing those golden-brown, crispy strips against the vibrant backdrop of the pizza is an absolute feast for the eyes. In pizza toppings, bacon truly stands out as a culinary superstar, turning an ordinary pizza into a genuinely extraordinary dinner.

---

Onions

Onions, a staple in countless dishes, have also carved out their niche in pizza toppings. Often overlooked in the face of meatier or more exotic options, onions are the unsung heroes that can transform your pizza experience.

Their natural sweetness, enhanced by the oven’s high heat, offers a pleasing counterpoint to the savory cheese and tangy tomato sauce, creating a harmony of flavors that resonates with each bite. The slight crunch they retain after baking adds an appealing textural element to the soft and gooey pizza, making every mouthful a delightful play of textures.

From the sharp bite of red onions to the mellow sweetness of caramelized ones, each variety brings a distinct flavor profile to the table. Even the sight of thinly sliced onions, glistening and slightly charred, adds an aesthetic appeal to the pizza.

Whether you enjoy them as the show’s star or in a supporting role alongside other toppings, onions, with their delicate balance of sweetness and sharpness, elevate your pizza from good to great.

---

Extra Cheese, Cheese, And More Cheese

Nothing quite matches the universal appeal of extra cheese in the grand spectrum of pizza toppings. Something about that extra layer of melted, gooey goodness sends a ripple of delight through the hearts of pizza lovers everywhere.

Whether it’s mozzarella, cheddar, parmesan, or a luxurious blend of multiple varieties, extra cheese promises an elevated pizza experience. It enhances the flavor, adding a creamy, savory richness that perfectly complements the tangy tomato sauce and crisp, golden crust.

When heated, the cheese melts into a sea of stretchy, stringy decadence that pulls apart with each bite, adding a level of satisfaction that’s both visual and sensory. The extra cheese layer’s slightly browned and bubbling surface is a sight, promising a delightful burst of flavor beneath.

So, whether you’re a purist enjoying a simple cheese pizza or an adventurous foodie experimenting with a multitude of toppings, that extra helping of cheese is a delicious homage to the comforting heart of pizza tradition, a testament to the adage that more really is more when it comes to cheese.

---

Peppers

In all their wide variety, Peppers have staked their claim in the pizza universe, offering an exciting dimension of flavor and color that is hard to resist. Their appeal is multifaceted – a perfect balance of sweetness, tang, and, depending on the variety, a dash of heat that livens up the pizza experience.

Their natural sugars caramelize as they roast in the oven, heightening their sweetness and adding a delectable, slightly smoky flavor that complements the savory cheese and tangy sauce. But peppers aren’t just about taste; they also contribute a delightful crunch, contrasting the soft and melted textures of the pizza.

The visual appeal of peppers should be considered. From the vibrant red of bell peppers to the deep green of jalapeños, they add a burst of color that makes the pizza aesthetically enticing.

Whether you’re a fan of the mild and sweet or crave the thrill of something spicier, peppers offer a versatile and flavorful topping choice that can turn your pizza into a culinary masterpiece.

---

Chicken

Chicken, a beloved staple in many cuisines, has taken flight in the pizza world, offering a lean, protein-packed option that’s as versatile as it is delicious. As a pizza topping, chicken presents a canvas for various flavors and preparations.

Whether it’s the smoky allure of BBQ chicken, the spicy kick of buffalo chicken, or the aromatic charm of chicken tikka, each version brings a unique taste profile to your pizza. The tender chunks of chicken provide a satisfying bite, adding a meaty heft that balances out the cheese and sauce.

As it bakes, the chicken absorbs the flavors of the other ingredients while imparting its savory essence to the overall composition of the pizza. The sight of golden, succulent chicken pieces scattered across a sea of melted cheese is tempting for any pizza lover.

So, whether you’re a fan of traditional toppings or seeking something a bit different, chicken offers a healthy, flavorful option that turns your pizza from a simple meal into a gastronomic delight.

---

Black Olives

With their unique combination of saltiness and subtle bitterness, black olives hold a special place in pizza toppings.

Unassuming yet undeniably flavorful, they bring a Mediterranean flair to your pizza, enhancing the overall taste with their distinctive character. Each slice of black olive carries a burst of flavor, providing a delightful contrast to the creamy cheese and tangy tomato sauce.

Their firm texture holds up well under the oven heat, adding an enjoyable bite that stands out amidst the softer elements of the pizza. They release a mild, nutty aroma that adds to the enticing bouquet of scents wafting from your pizza as they warm.

Visually, the dark, glossy rounds scattered against the vibrant backdrop of the pizza add an element of aesthetic appeal. Whether enjoyed as the singular star on a simple pizza or combined with many other toppings, black olives offer a taste of the Mediterranean that can elevate your pizza experience from everyday to extraordinary.

---

Spinach

Spinach, a powerhouse of nutrition, has found its way onto the pizza scene as a popular topping, offering a delightfully fresh and healthy twist to the classic dish.

Its mild, slightly earthy flavor brings a garden-fresh taste that harmonizes wonderfully with the robust cheese and tangy tomato sauce. As it wilts in the oven, spinach lends a delicate texture that contrasts beautifully with the crunch of the crust and the gooey melt of the cheese.

The vibrant green also adds a pop of color, making the pizza visually appealing and tasty. But spinach doesn’t just stop at taste and texture. Packed with vitamins and minerals, it adds a nutritious boost to your pizza.

Whether it’s part of a vegetarian feast, paired with creamy ricotta, or nestled among other toppings, spinach adds a layer of complexity and freshness to your pizza, turning it into a wholesome, gourmet treat.

---

Tomato and Basil

Tomato and basil, the quintessential duo of Italian cuisine, have a special place in pizza toppings. Their synergy is a testament to simplicity’s beauty, producing a fresh, vibrant, and universally beloved flavor profile.

Slices of ripe, juicy tomato offer a burst of natural sweetness and a slight acidity that cuts through the cheese’s richness, adding a refreshing and satisfying flavor. On the other hand, basil, with its aromatic, peppery notes, brings an herbaceous brightness that lifts the entire dish.

When heated, it infuses the pizza with its distinct aroma, creating an olfactory delight that’s as enjoyable as the taste. Visually, the ruby red of the tomatoes juxtaposed with the vivid green of the basil leaves makes for an eye-catching, delicious display.

Whether enjoyed as a classic Margherita or as part of a more complex topping medley, the tomato and basil combo is a timeless favorite that encapsulates the essence of pizza in its most authentic form.

---

Beef

With its robust, hearty flavor, ground beef has earned its place as a favored topping among pizza enthusiasts worldwide. Its appeal lies in its versatility and the rich, savory depth it brings to every pizza it graces.

When seasoned well and scattered over a pizza, the beef crumbles transform under the oven’s high heat, their exterior becoming beautifully browned and slightly crispy while retaining a juicy tenderness within. The ground beef imbues the cheese and sauce with its meaty essence as it cooks, creating a deliciously unified flavor profile.

The possibilities are endless, from a traditional ground beef and onion combination to a Mexican-inspired taco pizza. The visual appeal of golden-brown morsels of beef peeping through the blanket of melted cheese is undeniably mouthwatering.

Whether you enjoy it as a stand-alone star or paired with other toppings, ground beef brings a substantial, satisfying quality to your pizza, turning it into a genuinely comforting, hearty meal.

---

Ham

Ham, with its sweet and savory profile, holds a revered spot in the pantheon of pizza toppings. Its popularity spans across continents, starring in iconic pizza variations such as the Hawaiian pizza, where it’s paired with pineapple for a delightful play of flavors.

When used as a topping, the thin slices of ham add a succulent, satisfying, and flavorful meatiness. Under the oven’s heat, the ham’s edges crisp up, intensifying its flavor and adding a smoky charm. Its inherent sweetness provides a delightful counterpoint to the tangy tomato sauce and the creamy, salty cheese, creating a balanced harmony of flavors on your palate.

Visually, the pinkish hue of ham provides a delightful contrast against the golden cheese, making the pizza as pleasing to the eyes as it is to the taste buds.

You may prefer your ham coupled with other toppings or stealing the show on its own, this versatile topping is a tried-and-true favorite that can elevate your pizza experience to new delicious heights.

---

Pesto

Pesto, that vibrant, aromatic blend of basil, garlic, pine nuts, Parmesan, and olive oil, has earned its place as a beloved alternative to traditional pizza sauce and even as a topping in its own right.

With its bright, herbaceous flavor and creamy texture, pesto brings a touch of freshness that perfectly complements the warm, gooey cheese and crisp crust. Its bold, garlicky notes and the nutty undertone of the Parmesan add a depth of flavor that can transform any pizza into a gourmet delight.

When spread over the crust, pesto acts as a flavor-infused canvas for other toppings, enhancing their taste and lending a unique twist to the classic pizza profile. And let’s not forget the visual appeal: the rich, green hue of pesto offers a vibrant contrast to the typical red pizza sauce, making the pizza as tantalizing to the eyes as it is to the palate.

You might be a fan of the traditional pesto Genovese or prefer a modern spin with varieties like sun-dried tomato or arugula pesto, this versatile ingredient offers a refreshing alternative that can take your pizza experience to new, delicious heights.

---

Pulled Pork

Pulled pork, with its succulent texture and smoky, sweet flavor, has ventured beyond the realm of barbecue to make a name for itself in the world of pizza toppings.

A relative newcomer compared to traditional toppings, it’s quickly gaining popularity due to its unique flavor profile and satisfyingly meaty bite. The pulled pork shreds add a robust, hearty element to pizza, their rich flavor melding beautifully with the tangy tomato sauce and creamy cheese.

Each mouthful delivers an irresistible mix of sweetness, savoriness, and smokiness, creating a flavor explosion that’s hard to resist. Paired often with complementary toppings like caramelized onions or tangy barbecue sauce, pulled pork can transform a simple pizza into a gourmet delight.

Visually, the golden-brown, juicy strands of pork nestled amidst melted cheese offer a feast for the eyes, promising an equally satisfying feast for the palate. To both barbecue lovers and pizza enthusiasts looking for something different, pulled pork offers an exciting topping choice that elevates your pizza experience to delicious new levels.

---

Ham And Pineapple

The pairing of ham and pineapple, popularly known as the Hawaiian pizza, is a hot debate among pizza enthusiasts worldwide.

Despite the divide, its popularity is undeniable, as this unconventional duo offers an interplay of sweet and savory flavors that many find irresistible. The salty notes of ham complement the natural sweetness and slight tartness of pineapple, creating a balanced and unique flavor profile.

The ham lends a meaty heft to each slice, while the juicy pineapple pieces add a refreshing burst that cuts through the richness of the cheese and ham. As it bakes, the pineapple caramelizes slightly, intensifying its sweetness and adding a touch of complexity to the overall taste.

The vibrant yellow of the pineapple and the pink hue of the ham create a tasty contrast against the cheese backdrop. Love it or hate it, the ham and pineapple combo is an outstanding choice that stands out in the broad spectrum of pizza toppings.

---