in

America’s Favorite Ice Cream Flavors

Find your favorite on our list of the most popular flavors of ice cream.

It would be challenging to find someone who doesn’t like ice cream, perhaps because there are so many good flavors to choose from.

Ice cream flavor in cones blueberry ,lime ,pistachio ,almond ,orange ,chocolate ,vanilla and coffee

You might like your ice cream super sweet, a little salty, deliciously fruity, or irresistibly chocolatey.

Regardless of how you prefer this delectable delicacy, there’s a vast range of flavors to delight even the most particular of palates.

However, with so many flavors ready for scooping, it can be hard to decide which one should sit atop your sugar cone. 

If this is the case, don’t worry. We’ve got you covered.

Most Popular Ice Cream Flavors

Here are some of the most popular ice cream flavors in America so that you can decide with confidence.

Vanilla

Vanilla is a classic ice cream flavor that seems plain in appearance but offers the perfect canvas to dress up your dessert to suit your fancy. 

In fact, it’s one of the most popular flavors for a reason. As this flavor’s name implies, it’s made with vanilla, a bean that provides a lightly floral, caramel taste to the ice cream.

It’s creamy, smooth, and can be paired with anything, making it a fundamental go-to base for other, more complicated ice cream flavors, such as chocolate chip ice cream.

Whether you prefer your ice cream plain or topped with fudge, brownies, or cookies, vanilla is always a good place to start. 

It’s also the best choice if you are trying out a new ice cream shop and want to order something safe and reliably refreshing.

Finally, vanilla ice cream goes very well with hot desserts such as apple pie and brownies.


Chocolate

Like vanilla, chocolate is another classic ice cream flavor beloved by people of all ages.

From sumptuous milk chocolate to indulgent dark, there’s a chocolate ice cream for everyone. 

If you are a genuine chocolate lover, you might find that other chocolate-based ice cream flavors, such as chocolate fudge or mint chocolate chip, are too sweet for your taste.

In this case, pure chocolate ice cream is the way to go.

This flavor is perfect for those days when you are craving something chocolatey but don’t necessarily want a lot of additional sweetness.

Chocolate ice always works well as a base ingredient for a sundae or is paired with cakes, pies, and other desserts.


Coffee

Coffee is a unique ice cream flavor that’s perfect for those who love their morning cup of joe enough to enjoy it for dessert, too.

The flavor of this complexly flavored confection starts with coffee beans, which gives it a distinct and intense flavor that’s not for everyone.

However, if you are a coffee lover, you’ll probably find that this ice cream flavor is right up your alley.

It makes for a fantastic treat on a hot afternoon and may even trick your brain into feeling more energized due to the coffee flavor.

Coffee ice cream is not often paired with other desserts, but if you are a true coffee lover, you can try eating it with tiramisu. 

The intermingling icy cold richness pairs perfectly with thick custard and espresso-soaked ladyfingers. 


Cookie Dough

Cookie dough has been a popular ice cream flavor for years, and it’s not hard to see why.

You get a versatile vanilla ice cream base mixed with gobs of raw cookie dough for a double-dose dessert that can tame even the most voracious sweet tooth. 

The best cookie dough ice cream doesn’t skimp on the good stuff. You should get a bit of the titular ingredient in every single bite. 

It’s a fun and unique flavor, perfect for those who love both cookies and ice cream.

It’s also a delightful flavor that many people enjoy, so it’s excellent for daytime parties and events.

One of Haagen-Dazs best flavors, in my opinion, is their cookie dough, and it’s my personal favorite.


Strawberry

If you are looking for an ice cream flavor that’s not too heavy, strawberry is the ice cream for you. 

Strawberry is a refreshing and fruity ice cream flavor that tastes like summertime and childhood nostalgia.

People usually use real strawberries for the ice cream, which gives it a tart and slightly sweet flavor that’s perfect for a warm day.

This flavor also pairs well with other fruits, such as blueberries, raspberries, or blackberries.

You can also pair it with chocolate sauce or chocolate chips for a take on chocolate-dipped strawberries. 


Birthday Cake

Birthday cake is a fun and festive ice cream flavor that combines the best part of birthday parties into a celebration!

It looks exciting, especially to kids, because of the rainbow sprinkles and whorls of icing that dance through the cake-flavored base.

Of course, the sprinkles and buttercream aren’t the only aspects that make it “birthday cake” ice cream.

What elevates this treat to next-level flavor is the addition of the iconic centerpiece to most of our childhood fiestas: classic yellow cake. 

If you want to make this yourself and don’t want to buy a whole cake, you can purchase or make a few cupcakes instead.


Rocky Road

Rocky Road is a highly-rated ice cream flavor that’s perfect for those who want to enjoy both the texture and taste.

It consists of a chocolate ice cream base studded with marshmallows for a pillowy puff of sweetness and almonds for the irresistible crunch. 

The most common nut used in rocky road ice cream is almonds, but feel free to experiment with your favorite nuts.

You can also add chocolate chips or other mix-ins to make this flavor your own.

Rocky road is an excellent choice for those looking for a flavor that’s not too sweet but still has a lot of depth and flavor.


Pistachio

Pistachio is a nutty, slightly salty ice cream flavor that comes in an inviting shade of green. 

The luscious blend of nutty pistachios and smooth ice cream is refreshing without being too sweet. 

To make this flavor, you need to use real pistachio nuts. You would blend the nuts into the ice cream base, giving it a distinct flavor and a slightly green color.

People might choose to pair this ice cream with other flavors, such as chocolate or strawberry, but you can also enjoy pistachio ice cream on its own.

If you prefer to eschew traditional flavors in favor of something a little more mature, pistachio is calling your name. It’s also a classic gelato flavor if you prefer gelato over ice cream.


Mint Chocolate Chip

Mint chocolate chip is a refreshing and cooling ice cream flavor.

The taste bud tingling sweet mint compliments dark chocolate chunks, combining to form a frosty sweet most find hard to resist. 

I recommend crushing cookie pieces like Mint Oreos for even more texture, as the strong mint taste can still shine through even the most pronounced mix-ins. Ben and Jerry’s make a great mint cookie if you don’t want to mix it yourself!

Many people rate mint chocolate chips very highly, but it is one of the more controversial ice cream flavors. You’ll likely love mint chocolate chip ice cream or hate it, but nothing in between!


Butter Pecan

Butter pecan is a rich, creamy, and smooth ice cream flavor for those who enjoy a more savory, buttery, and nutty flavor profile over a sweet or fruity one.

This ice cream uses a vanilla ice cream base and includes butter, giving it a unique flavor that some say is reminiscent of frosting.

It’s also a very dense and heavy flavor, so it’s a good selection for those who want a filling and satisfying treat.

You can substitute pecans for other nuts, like almonds, but there’s something special about the specific flavor profile of pecans in this ice cream.

Like Pistachio ice cream, it’s an ice cream flavor that suits a more mature palette, making it a favorite among adults.


Chocolate Chip

Chocolate chip ice cream is simple, sweet, and oh so delightful.

It’s an ideal dessert if you don’t mind appreciating the simplicity of vanilla ice cream but want to switch things up ever so slightly.

Chocolate chips add the perfect amount of sweetness and crunch to an otherwise classic ice cream flavor.

This timeless ice cream flavor will never go out of style, making it suitable for those who have difficulty choosing between decadent chocolate and smooth vanilla. 


Green Tea

Green Tea ice cream is another slightly controversial flavor that people love or could go without.

Like coffee ice cream, it helps to be a fan of the beverage before you decide to try this flavor in ice cream form.

This flavor is made with green tea powder, which gives it a distinct and slightly bitter taste.

Green tea ice cream is often paired with other flavors to help balance out the bitterness, such as chocolate, strawberry, or pistachio.

If you’re looking for something unique and different, this green tea ice cream might be the next flavor for you to try.


Cookies and Cream

Cookies and cream is a classic ice cream flavor often associated with kids, but people of all ages enjoy it.

It’s made with a vanilla ice cream base and has chunks of cookies mixed throughout.

The most common cookie to use is an Oreo, but you can use any type of cookie that you’re currently craving.

You can even make homemade cookies to add to the ice cream!

Cookies and cream is a sweet crowd pleaser because it brings a little texture to an otherwise straightforward flavor. 


Rainbow Sherbet

Rainbow sherbet is a fruity, tangy, and refreshing ice cream flavor that consists of different fruit juices– usually raspberry, orange, and lime– with a touch of cream. 

This results in a light, fluffy sherbet that melts quickly on the tongue.

It’s ideal for the dog days of summer and deck-side pool parties because the flavor balances the mouthfeel of ice cream with an invigorating citrus flavor.

Ultimately, rainbow sherbet is a tasty hybrid frozen dessert that’s great for those who do not like the heaviness or ultra creaminess of ice cream, want a bit more depth than sorbet, and love fruity flavors.


Rum Raisin

Rum raisin is another ice cream flavor best suited for adults, as the alcohol content can be too much for children. 

Rum raisin is a rich and flavorful ice cream that’s one of the few frozen desserts that makes sense on cold winter nights, especially when paired with hot beverages like hot cocoa.

This sophisticated frozen treat starts with a rum-soaked raisin base, which gives it a unique flavor that some love and others despise. It provides a depth of flavor and spicy warmth to the otherwise chilly delight.

If you’re not a huge fan of raisins, you probably won’t enjoy this flavor, but it’s worth a try if you are!


Cotton Candy

Last but not least, we have cotton candy!

This is a fun and unique ice cream flavor that kids and adults who are young at heart adore. 

It’s a delightfully sweet cotton candy-flavored ice cream base, usually with bits of cotton candy confection speckled into the swirls of pink and blue. 

The result is a light, fluffy, attractive, and sweet treat that fits right in at birthday parties, carnivals, and festivals.

This flavor is also great for those who want something a little bit different than the classic ice cream flavors but still feels familiar, as the cotton candy flavor is one that most people are already familiar with.


Most Popular Ice Cream Flavors

  1. Vanilla
  2. Chocolate
  3. Coffee
  4. Cookie Dough
  5. Strawberry
  6. Birthday Cake
  7. Rocky Road
  8. Pistachio 
  9. Mint Chocolate Chip
  10. Butter Pecan
  11. Chocolate Chip
  12. Green Tea
  13. Cookies & Cream
  14. Rainbow Sherbet 
  15. Rum Raisin
  16. Cotton Candy

Final Thoughts

These delicious flavors are some of America’s most popular ice cream flavors.

Of course, there are still many more options to choose from, and ice cream shops have become increasingly creative and experimental with their flavors in recent years.

But these classic ice cream flavors will always have a special place in our hearts (and stomachs).

So the next time you’re purchasing ice cream, or are feeling like combining some ingredients right at home, give one of these ice cream flavors a try!

This page may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we'll earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Written by Erin Elizabeth

Erin lives in East Passyunk and enjoys checking out the local restaurants in South Philly and beyond. Her favorite restaurants are those with spicy food and outdoor seating so that she can bring along her dog, Miss Piggy.