in

21 Most Popular Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream Flavors

We’ve ranked the top pint flavors to get the next time you need some ice cream.

It’s no secret that ice cream is one of the best comfort foods out there. Ben & Jerry’s, in particular, is known for its ability to make the perfect sweet and tasty treat for almost any occasion.  This Vermont-based company is dedicated to making high-quality and delicious ice cream that’s packed full of mix-ins and fantastic flavors. 

From unique ice cream flavors to non-dairy pints to core ice cream, Ben & Jerry’s truly has something for everyone. And not only do they deliver on their promise of incredible ice cream, but they’re committed to making the world a better place through their products.

ben and jerry's pint of ice cream

With so many ice cream options, the freezer aisle at the store can start to feel overwhelming. So what are the best Ben and jerry flavors on the market?

Whether you like overly sweet desserts or are looking for a more mild flavor, there’s an ideal Ben & Jerry’s pint for you. 

Here is your guide to 21 of the best Ben and Jerrys flavors to help you find the best option.

Best Ben & Jerry’s Flavors

  1. Americone Dream
  2. The Tonight Dough
  3. Half Baked
  4. Cherry Garcia
  5. Phish Food
  6. Strawberry Cheesecake
  7. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
  8. Chocolate Fudge Brownie
  9. New York Super Fudge Chunk
  10. Chunky Monkey
  11. Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch
  12. Peanut Butter Fudge Core
  13. Milk & Cookies
  14. Chocolate Therapy
  15. S’mores
  16. Pistachio Pistachio
  17. Triple Caramel Chunk
  18. Chubby Hubby
  19. Peanut Butter Cup
  20. Urban Bourbon
  21. Cinnamon Buns

Americone Dream

While Ben & Jerry’s offers a huge range of vanilla-flavored ice cream flavors, Americone Dream stands out as one of the best choices on the market. 

Endorsed by Late Show host Stephen Colbert, Americone Dream is packed with flavor and different textures. It comes with a vanilla ice cream base, fudge-covered waffle cone pieces, and a rich caramel swirl. With heaping amounts of crunchy and sweet toppings, it’s no surprise that Americone Dream is one of the best Ben and Jerry flavors you can buy.

And not only does this flavor taste delicious, but every purchase goes towards a good cause. Every sale helps support the Stephen Colbert Americone Dream Fund for veterans, disadvantaged kids, and environmental issues.


The Tonight Dough

This Ben & Jerry’s flavor, inspired by The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon, is not only one of my favorite ice cream flavors, but it’s one of the most popular Ben & Jerry’s flavors since its release in 2015. 

The Tonight Dough is completely packed full of sweet and delicious toppings that are perfect for any ice cream craving. Chocolate cookie swirls and large chunks of both chocolate chip and peanut butter cookie dough are combined with caramel and chocolate ice cream to create this classic Ben & Jerry’s treat. 

The Tonight Dough provides even more opportunity to put your money towards a great cause. Proceeds from this flavor go towards the SeriousFun Children’s Network of global camps.


Half Baked

Another classic Ben & Jerry’s flavor, Half baked, has earned its spot as the most popular Ben & Jerry’s flavor year after year. 

This flavor offers the best of both worlds, with a mixture of chocolate and vanilla ice cream and large chunks of both fudge brownie pieces and chocolate chip cookie dough. If you’re torn between all the flavors Ben and Jerry’s sells, Half Baked gives you all the sweet and delicious flavor you could want in one pint.

Half Baked has been a classic, top-selling flavor for years, and it’s easy to see why it receives so much acclaim. In my opinion,  you can never go wrong when you reach for this Ben & Jerry’s staple. 


Cherry Garcia

Coming in at number two on the list of Ben and Jerry’s most popular flavors is Cherry Garcia. Named in honor of the Grateful Dead’s Jerry Garcia, this fruity flavor is the perfect snack when you’re looking for something sweet. 

The creamy cherry ice cream base is made even more delicious with a combination of large cherry pieces and fudge flakes. As one of the most iconic and well-known flavors, Cherry Garcia is worth a try for anyone in the mood for a lighter, fruity option.


Phish Food

Born out of a collaboration with the rock band PHISH, this instrumental Ben and Jerry’s flavor is not only fun and original but is one of the best tasting Ben & Jerry’s flavors out there. 

Phish Food comes with a combination of chocolate ice cream, a caramel swirl, gooey marshmallow swirls, and fish-shaped fudge pieces. And with a portion of the band’s royalties going towards environmental efforts in Vermont, all sales of this popular flavor go towards a great cause. 

Phish Food is one of my go-to flavors for a sweet and extremely rich dessert with a pint that’s packed full of delicious toppings


Strawberry Cheesecake

Ben & Jerry’s has historically created delicious and popular fruit-based flavors, and their Strawberry Cheesecake ice cream is no exception.

As far as Ben & Jerry’s loaded flavors go, Strawberry Cheesecake is on the simpler side, with strawberry cheesecake flavored ice creams, strawberry pieces, and a graham cracker swirl. 

While plenty of other companies sell this flavor, Ben & Jerry’s Strawberry Cheesecake has fantastic flavors and a buttery, flaky graham cracker swirl that sets it apart from other brands. It’s sweet, creamy, and rich, making it a perfect pick when you’re craving some ice cream.


Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

With so many scaled-up, exciting Ben & Jerry’s flavors today, some of the simpler, classic flavors, like Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, often fly under the radar. But when you’re craving something to satisfy a sweet tooth, this flavor is a delicious option.

While almost every ice cream brand has a basic cookie dough flavor, Ben & Jerry’s chocolate chip cookie dough is one of the best. In fact, Ben & Jerry’s created the world’s first batch of chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream in 1984, and it has remained one of their most popular flavors ever since.

With vanilla ice cream and plenty of chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough inside, this Ben & Jerry’s flavor is a classic pint with a sweet and satisfying taste.


Chocolate Fudge Brownie

Ben & Jerry’s offers a huge range of chocolate-based flavors, but in my opinion, their Chocolate Fudge Brownie flavor is one of the best choices for any chocolate lover. 

Another classic, understated flavor,  Chocolate Fudge Brownie, is packed full of different chocolate flavors and textures. It includes a creamy chocolate ice cream base, as well as gooey fudge brownie pieces.

What makes this flavor even sweeter is that gobs of fudge brownies are made in New York’s Greyston Bakery as a part of their mission to create jobs for low-income residents. 


New York Super Fudge Chunk

Created to help Ben & Jerry’s break into the New York market, New York Super Fudge Chunk is packed to the lid with flavor. With five different mix-in toppings, the huge range of flavors and textures in this ice cream earns it its place on the list of best Ben & Jerrys flavors.

While all the add-ins may seem a bit over the top, the combination of toppings makes this ice cream rich, flavorful, and unique. The chocolate ice cream base is full of white and dark chocolate fudge chunks, walnuts, pecans, and chocolate-covered almonds. 

If nuts are your favorite ice cream topping, you’re in luck with New York Super Fudge Chunk. The combination of different varieties of chocolate and nuts gives this flavor a spot as one of the most original and satisfying Ben & Jerry’s pints. 


Chunky Monkey

It’s widely known that Ben & Jerry’s excels at creating unique and fun ice cream flavors, and this is easy to see with the creation of their Chunky Monkey flavor.

Chunky Monkey comes with a creamy banana ice cream base, complete with large fudge chunks and walnut pieces. While the combination of flavors and toppings itself is relatively simple, the rich banana taste and classic mix-ins make Chunky Monkey a flavorful and memorable flavor.


Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch

Previously known as Coffee Heath Bar Crunch, Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch is perfect for any coffee fan with a sweet tooth. 

This sweet and rich ice cream contains a strong coffee-flavored base with large chunks of fudge-covered chocolate pieces. The coffee and toffee are an excellent combination of taste and texture, making this a classic Ben & Jerry’s flavor.

If you enjoyed the original Coffee Heath Bar Crunch ice cream, you’ll love the crunchy, buttery flavor of toffee in Ben & Jerry’s coffee ice cream. The name change stems from the company’s commitment to switch to only Fairtrade Certified ingredients, so not only will you love the taste of the new toffee pieces, but you can feel great about Ben & Jerry’s value-led sourcing. 


Peanut Butter Fudge Core

While Ben & Jerry’s flavors were always fantastic on their own, they took their flavors to the next level by adding cores to their pints. Ben & Jerry’s core ice creams come with a thick, gooey center, made up of some of the best ice cream ingredients, surrounded by Ben & Jerry’s ice cream and other mix-ins. 

Peanut Butter Fudge Core is one of the best core flavors, especially for peanut butter lovers. The peanut butter fudge center is surrounded by a mix of chocolate and peanut butter ice cream, as well as miniature peanut butter cups. 

While the core flavors include cookie dough, brownie batter, salted caramel, and more, the gooey and rich peanut butter fudge makes it the top choice among the core Ben & Jerry’s pints.


Milk & Cookies

Like everyone else, I love the classic taste of dipping cookies in milk. With Ben & Jerry’s Milk & Cookies flavor, you can get that same delicious taste in frozen ice cream form.

This ice cream is a huge step up from traditional milk and cookies, with a vanilla ice cream base, chocolate cookie swirl, and chocolate chip and double chocolate chip cookies mixed in. It’s sweet, rich, and includes huge cookie chunks throughout the pint to make every spoonful flavorful and delicious.

With excellent flavor and a variety of cookie pieces scattered throughout the base, this ice cream will transport you right back to the nostalgic taste of milk and cookies.


Chocolate Therapy

Chocolate Therapy is the perfect ice cream flavor for the biggest chocolate lovers out there. Ben & Jerry’s ice cream pints are already one of my favorite comfort foods, and this chocolate-loaded flavor is an ideal choice when you’re looking to treat yourself.

Chocolate Therapy has an assortment of chocolate flavors and textures, including creamy chocolate ice cream, chocolate pudding, ice cream swirls, and chocolate cookies.

While the abundance of chocolate ingredients may be too over the top for some, this ice cream is rich, indulgent, and perfect for anyone who can’t get enough chocolate.


S’mores

While roasting marshmallows around a campfire is always enjoyable, getting the delicious and gooey taste of s’mores can be a huge, messy process. Ben & Jerry’s makes it easier to get the great taste of s’mores with their chocolatey s’mores flavor.

Their Gimme S’mores flavor is now around full-time, with all the elements of sweet and indulgent campfire s’mores. It has a toasted marshmallow ice cream with a combination of chocolate cookie swirls, fudge flakes, and a buttery and flakey graham cracker swirl. 

If you love s’mores but don’t like the mess or hassle, this flavor provides the same great taste in an original ice cream flavor.


Pistachio Pistachio

While pistachio ice cream definitely isn’t for everyone, Ben & Jerry’s Pistachio Pistachio ice cream flavor is worth a try. It has a rich, nutty flavor that makes it stand out from the pistachio flavors offered by other ice cream companies.

The pistachio flavored ice cream is super sweet and creamy, while the numerous pistachios scattered in the ice cream add a crunch and some additional saltiness. I also found that it tastes much more like actual pistachios as opposed to the bright green, overly sweet pistachio flavors from other companies, putting Pistachio Pistachio a step above other alternatives.


Triple Caramel Chunk

If you’re a big fan of caramel, Triple Caramel Chunk might be the best Ben & Jerry’s flavor for you. It’s full of sweet and delicious caramel ice cream and toppings, with everything a caramel lover could ask for in a pint of ice cream.

This flavor offers caramel on top of caramel – creamy caramel ice cream, chewy, fudge-covered caramel pieces, and a caramel swirl.

There are a lot of caramel ice cream flavors on the market, but Ben & Jerry’s goes over the top with a delicious caramel ice cream and two tasty toppings mixed in.


Chubby Hubby

One of Ben & Jerry’s most original ice cream flavors, Chubby Hubby is loaded with mix-ins and toppings that make it unique and irresistible. With so many different flavors packed into a pint, it’s no surprise that Chubby Hubby has been a popular and well-loved Ben & Jerry’s flavor for years.

The vanilla malt ice cream gives this ice cream a light taste, while the gooey peanut butter and fudge swirls add even more flavor. My favorite part of the ice cream, however, is the peanutty-fudge-covered pretzel pieces, which add a crunch and hint of salt to this sweet treat.

This indulgent and decadent flavor is a Ben & Jerry’s staple, with a combination of sweet and salty ingredients that perfectly complement each other.


Peanut Butter Cup

Ben & Jerry’s has a huge number of flavors centered around peanut butter cups, but you can’t go wrong with the simple and classic Peanut Butter Cup ice cream. 

This flavor has a strong and flavorful peanut butter cup ice cream base, and it comes packed with large peanut butter cup chunks. 

While almost every ice cream company has its own iteration of this classic flavor, Ben & Jerry’s version is one of the best. From the sweet taste of the ice cream to the smooth peanut butter cups, everything in this flavor is ideal for peanut butter lovers. And with plenty of peanut butter cups spread throughout the ice cream, you can get the perfect peanut-buttery bite in every spoonful. 


Urban Bourbon

Urban Bourbon, a relatively new flavor from Ben & Jerry’s, offers an indulgent and delicious ice cream option that’s completely packed with flavor.  

The burnt caramel ice cream has a much richer and more unique taste than Ben & Jerry’s traditional caramel, and it’s paired perfectly with fudge flakes, almonds, and bourbon caramel swirls. 

The strong flavors combine to make a strong, delectable, and original scoop of ice cream. It’s also one of the only Ben & Jerry’s flavors with an alcohol base, giving it a slightly boozy flavor – although it doesn’t contain any actual alcohol, so it can be enjoyed by the whole family. 


Cinnamon Buns

While cinnamon buns are already delicious on their own, Ben & Jerry’s puts all the sweetness of this pastry into an incredible frozen treat with their Cinnamon Bun Ice cream flavor. 

Ben & Jerry’s combines a caramel ice cream base with chunks of cinnamon bun dough and a cinnamon streusel swirl to make a perfectly sweet and creamy dessert. With all the toppings and cinnamon-flavored mix-ins, Cinnamon Buns ice cream is the perfect solution when you’re craving something rich and flavorful.


Final Thoughts

Whether you’re looking for a simple, traditional ice cream or a unique flavor you can’t find with any other brand, Ben & Jerry’s has something perfect for you. With so many options that anyone will love, Ben & Jerry’s pints are one of the best ways to treat yourself.

You can take your pick from any of these top 21 best and most popular Ben & Jerry’s flavors to find your new favorite treat to enjoy.

This page may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we'll earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Written by Ryan F.

Ryan is a Philadelphia local who enjoys checking out Philly's restaurant scene every chance he can. He grew up in South Jersey and now lives in Philadelphia's Point Breeze neighborhood. Ryan also enjoys traveling and checking out local eateries in every city he visits.