Our Favorite Ice Cream Toppings Ranked

Delicious toppings for the ultimate ice cream sundae.

You can probably list your favorite ice cream flavors off by heart. But what about the toppings you have smothered on top?

ice cream sundae toppings

You can enjoy your favorite flavors on their own, sure – but what about if you want to mix things up and give it an extra special dose of sugary goodness?

The right toppings can take your ice cream to the next level. But which are the best ice cream toppings and where would they rank in a list?

Best Ice Cream Toppings

Check out our favorite ice cream toppings and tell us your favorites in the comments!

Hot Fudge

The creme de la creme of ice cream toppings is undoubtedly hot chocolate fudge.

hot fudge on ice cream

This ice cream topping will take your cold treat to the next level, delivering a good dose of chocolatey goodness to boot.

The genius about the hot chocolate fudge topping is that it will complement virtually every flavor.

No matter if you prefer plain vanilla, choc chip, or more adventurous flavors, hot chocolate fudge will send your taste buds into a frenzy.


Ice cream wouldn’t be ice cream if it didn’t come with sprinkles.

ice cream with sprinkles

This is the classic topping that most ice cream connoisseurs opt for, and with good reason.

There are so many different sprinkles to choose from that you’ll easily find the one that best compliments your favorite flavors.

If you prefer more flavored ice cream, sprinkles are the perfect addition to your ice cream if you don’t want them to impact on the overall flavor too much.


Fancy a drizzly treat without the chocolate? Caramel is the way to go.

ice cream with caramel

This sweet topping has a rich flavor that will completely transform your plain cone into a taste sensation.

The best thing about caramel is that it also works well with virtually any flavor!

So get drizzling this buttery treat over your favorite ice creams to give it that extra special something.


Oreos are a beloved treat around the globe.

ice cream with oreo topping

So it’s only natural that people like to have it crumbled over their classic ice cream cones!

Cookies and cream is one of the more popular flavors, too, which Oreos can complement perfectly.

They’re also vegan, which makes them a great treat regardless of your dietary requirements.

If you want an added crunch to your ice cream, get topping it with Oreos!

Cookie Dough

You’ve had cookie dough ice cream, but what about using it for an ice cream topping?

cookie dough ice cream

We’re sure this isn’t something you might have thought of, but trust us – it’s well worth a go.

You’ll get two lots of snacks all from one tasty treat! If you want to really make the most of your cookie dough topping, why not try it with some cookie dough flavored ice cream? 

Whipped Cream

Fancy more of a classic topping? Then whipped cream is the way to go.

whipped cream topping

This is another classic topping for Sundaes, and for good reason.

There’s just something about the combination of whipped cream and ice cream which sets our mouths watering!

The great thing about whipped cream is that it’s another versatile topping that can be combined with multiple other toppings.

Why not try adding caramel or sprinkles to your whipped cream topping?

Hard Chocolate Coating

Everyone knows that chocolate just makes everything taste a billion times better. So why not try adding a hard chocolate coating to your classic cone?

ice cream with chocolate shell

The cold temperature of the ice cream cools the liquid chocolate down so that it encases the sweet treat. Perfect for those who have a sweet tooth!

The great thing about this topping is that you can even choose the chocolate that best suits you, whether that’s dark, milk, white, or even ruby chocolate.

Melted Marshmallows

Another ingenious topping of course is melted marshmallows, although you may not have thought of adding this to your ice cream.

marshmallows ice cream

The great thing about melted marshmallows is that they can combine with other toppings such as caramel, hot chocolate fudge, or sprinkles to create the ultimate dessert.

If you’re a fan of smores, you need to give this topping a go!


Imagine your favorite ice cream flavor topped with your favorite cereal. A delicious thought, isn’t it?

cereal topping on ice cream

There’s a reason that companies like Ben & Jerry’s have started making cereal flavored ice cream.

The combination just works really well! Why not try giving this topping a go at home and see what you think?


Want to trick your brain into thinking you’re eating healthier snacks? Adding some of your favorite fruits is the way to go.

strawberries on ice cream

If you want to give your strawberry ice cream an added boost, adding actual strawberries can help give it some extra flavor.

The great thing about this topping is the possibilities are endless in terms of which fruit you can add!

Opt for some classics such as pineapple, orange, or apple, or go for something more adventurous.

Peanut Butter Cups

Peanut butter cups are one of America’s favorite treats. So it’s only natural that you’ll want to include them with every meal!

peanut butter cups on ice cream

Why not try adding some peanut butter cups to your favorite ice creams to help take them to the next level?

If you’re a peanut butter cup lover, this is definitely the topping you should opt for.


If you’re nutty about nuts, then of course you’ll want to add them to your favorite ice cream flavors!

nuts on ice cream

Try crumbling your favorite nuts over the top to give your ice cream a little extra crunch.

Pecans or walnuts are a great choice, or even go the whole hog and add some pistachios to the top of your pistachio ice cream for some added crunch.

You can also try peanuts, cashews, almonds, or even hazelnuts.

Best Ice Cream Toppings

  1. Hot Fudge
  2. Sprinkles
  3. Caramel
  4. Oreos
  5. Cookie Dough
  6. Whipped Cream
  7. Hard Chocolate Coating
  8. Melted Marshmallow
  9. Cereal
  10. Fruit
  11. Peanut Butter Cups
  12. Nuts

Final Thoughts

So there we have it! The best ice cream toppings ranked in order. Why not mix and match your favorite toppings to create the ultimate ice cream Sundae?

Or try something new to tempt your taste buds!

Can’t decide which tasty topping to try? Why not try them all in order! Let us know in the comments which toppings you like best!

This page may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we'll earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

One Comment

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Written by Erin Elizabeth

Erin lives in East Passyunk and enjoys checking out the local restaurants in South Philly and beyond. Her favorite restaurants are those with spicy food and outdoor seating so that she can bring along her dog, Miss Piggy.