Our Favorite Store-Bought Steak Sauces

Add these popular steak sauces to your next steak dinner.

Choosing a favorite brand of steak sauce can turn into a heated argument. Devoted fans of the most popular steak sauce brands will defend their choices with all their heart. Others will argue that you should never use steak sauce on a high-quality steak.

A1 steak sauce brand on top of a table

I’m here to tell you to listen to your taste buds. Steak sauces are a great condiment and should be in everyone’s cupboard. They work great as marinades, toppings, dips, and more for all types of meat and vegetables. 

Do you like your steak sauce spicy, tangy, savory, or zesty? There are many different brands of steak sauce for you to try. But which ones are the best? Today, I’ll cover my picks for the best steak sauce brands on the market. 

Even if you don’t know the difference between a sirloin or ribeye steak, this article will help you find the best steak sauce brands that match your favorite tastes. 

Best Steak Sauce Brands

Ready to improve the flavor of your favorite steak, burger, or dish? Here are my picks for the best steak sauce brands. 

Peter Luger Steak Sauce

Established in 1887 in New York City, Peter Luger Steak House is an American classic and one of the most famous steakhouses in the world.

They now offer the official Peter Luger Steak House Old Fashioned Sauce for sale online and you can enjoy it at home. 

A cross between a traditional cocktail sauce and steak sauce, this sauce has a spicy horseradish kick combined with hints of smoky flavors.

This fat-free sauce works best as a marinade for all types of meat or as an ingredient in meatloaf or hamburgers. 

Inside the bottle, you’ll find a mix of tomatoes, vinegar, sugar, corn syrup, horseradish, molasses, and spices. This gives Peter Luger Steak Sauce its distinct combination of sweet, tangy, and savory flavors. 

Lea & Perrins Bold Steak Sauce

First launched in 1837, Lea & Perrins mastered their first Worcestershire sauce. Today the company ships its famous sauces worldwide to over 130 countries around the world. 

Lea & Perrins bold steak sauce offers a combination of rich and smooth flavors.

This bold-flavored steak sauce combines Worcestershire sauce, molasses, onions, garlic, and salt to create a perfect blend of sweet, zesty, savory, and smoky flavors for you to enjoy.

This steak sauce is ideal for marinades or as a topping on your favorite steak cut.

The thickness of this sauce also makes it an ideal condiment for topping sandwiches and burgers.

A-1 Steak Sauce

The A-1 brand is synonymous with steak sauce. Chances are if you request a bottle of steak sauce at a restaurant, the waiter will provide a bottle of traditional A-1 steak sauce

The sauce has a unique flavor profile that combines zesty, tart, sour, salty, and sweet tastes.

It’s a burst of flavor for your tastebuds. A-1 accomplishes this variety of flavors through a mix of tomatoes, oranges, garlic, and secret spices.

A-1 is a versatile sauce and chefs use it for dips, toppings, marinades, and more.

It works great on all types of meat and vegetables. It’s also great for grilling.

Primal Kitchen Organic Steak Sauce and Marinade

Primal Kitchen offers a variety of healthy and organic products. Their steak sauce meets stringent health requirements and tastes amazing.

This organic steak sauce recipe helps soak up flavors and seal moisture in your meats. 

One of the healthiest options on the list, Primal Kitchen’s steak sauce is organic, certified paleo, keto certified, vegan, and Whole 30 approved. This lets cooks with dietary concerns enjoy a smoky and zesty steak sauce. 

Flavors come from a mix of balsamic vinegar, tomato paste, tamarind, oranges, ginger, onion, garlic, and more.

If you’ve been looking for a healthy steak sauce that is full of flavor, this is your best bet. 

Country Bob’s All Purpose Sauce

“Country Bob” Edison has been selling his signature sauces since 1968.

They offer a variety of sauces and marinades but I’m partial to their All Purpose Sauce. This sauce tastes great on everything. I’ve used it for marinades, grilling, or dipping. 

While the ingredient list is simple, Country Bob found a perfect ratio of ingredients to create their all-purpose sauce.

The mix of tomatoes, vinegar, sugar, molasses, salt, onions, garlic, and cornstarch compliments almost any dish. 

This all-purpose sauce is great on steaks, shrimp, fish, pulled pork, baked potatoes, baked beans, and more. 

Delmonicos Classic 1837 Steak Sauce

Another iconic American steakhouse, Delmonicos has been synonymous with fine dining since 1837 and claims to be the first fine dining restaurant in the United States.

Today, you can enjoy their world-famous 1837 steak sauce at home.

The 1837 Steak Sauce offers a complex flavor profile that features a rich and bold taste.

The ingredient list includes standout ingredients like white wine, honey, molasses, garlic, and apple cider vinegar. This gives the sauce its distinct flavors.

This sauce goes great with all types of steak, meatloaf, beef ribs, chicken, lamb chops, and pork chops. Feel free to use it as a marinade or topping for your favorite dish.  

Heinz 57

The secret blend of ingredients in Heinz 57 Sauce has excited tastebuds for over 90 years.

The sauce’s distinct orange-yellow color and taste are unique to Heinz 57 Sauce and the company has often advertised the sauce as “ketchup with a kick.”

Heinz 57 uses a base of tomato, white vinegar, and malt vinegar for its sauce.

Other unique ingredients include raisin juice concentrate, mustard flour, turmeric, and apple puree. This gives the sauce its distinct mix of tang and zest. 

Perfect on steaks, burgers, or veggies, you should add a bottle of Heinz 57 to your shopping list if you love trying different steak sauces and marinades. 

Shula’s Special No. 347

Started by Coach Don Shula in 1989, Shula’s Steakhouse is one of the most prestigious steakhouse chains in the United States.

shula's steak sauce

Shula’s Special No 347 Sauce is a perfect complement for steaks, burgers, and vegetables. 

This citrus-based sauce found its way into many of my BBQ recipes.

The sauce has a similar flavor to A1 but leans heavily on tart flavors that come from the mix of orange zest, lemons, and grapefruit juices.

The sauce combines traditional steak sauce ingredients like tomato puree, distilled vinegar, garlic, and onion to create a delicious flavor combination.

HP Sauce

HP Sauce has a legendary status in the UK and is an icon of British culture.

The original HP brown sauce offers a distinct flavor from its closely guarded secret recipe.

Since the 1870s, HP Sauce has been a staple product for British families.

While the recipe is secret, the main ingredients include tomato, malt vinegar, spirit vinegar, sugars, dates, and tamarind. 

You’ll find HP sauce is great on almost everything. Whether used as a marinade or on a burger, HP sauce is a great addition. It is also an essential component of a full English breakfast.  

London Pub, Sauce Steak & Chop

I keep a bottle of London Pub, Sauce Steak & Chop in my cupboard when I want my meal to be extra savory.

This sauce is similar to HP Sauce but offers a unique blend of savory spices that is unmatched.

I find the London Pub Sauce is a perfect match for London Broil, pork chops, or a big juicy grilled burger 

The sauce has a mix of flavors that come from vinegar, tomato paste, apple puree, Worcestershire sauce, and sugar.

Blended, London Pub Sauce is great as a meat marinade or as a topping for your favorite burger or sandwich. 

Lea & Perrins Traditional Steak Sauce

Not to be outdone by their Bold Sauce, Lea & Perrins Traditional Steak Sauce is amazing as well. This thick and creamy sauce is ideal for marinades, dipping, or topping.

This fat-free and cholesterol-free sauce means you can add flavor to your dishes without ruining your diet.

It has a savory flavor that combines the flavors of Lea & Perrins Worcestershire sauce with tomato puree, molasses, lemon flavor, and tamarind to create a unique flavor profile. 

If you love the flavor of Worcestershire but want a thicker version, this sauce from Lea & Perrins is the best you’ll find on the market. 

Crystal Steak Sauce

Crystal Steak Sauce is one of the healthier options on the list. This sauce is non-GMO, gluten-free, Kosher, and Halal.

crystal steak sauce

If you have special dietary concerns, Crystal Steak Sauce is a great option for your marinades and dishes. 

This tomato-based sauce is versatile and has a tangy flavor. Crystal uses a mix of tomato, distilled vinegar, raisins, corn syrup, orange, lemon, grapefruit, and tamarind to create its unique flavor profile.

The sauce is thick enough to use as a topping but works great as a marinade as well.

Feel free to add Crystal Steak Sauce to your beef, lamb, fish, poultry, or vegan dishes. 

365 Whole Foods Organic Steak Sauce

Whole Foods offers a USDA organic, non-GMO, and vegan steak sauce. The 365 Whole Foods Organic Steak Sauce is ideal for chefs looking for a healthy option to marinade their meals in. 

365 steak sauce

This steak sauce has a similar taste to A1 but is tangier. It’s also not as thick as A1. I found this sauce worked best as a marinade for steaks, chops, and vegetables.

Grilling and broiling the marinated meats brings out the flavors of this steak sauce. 

The tangy flavors come from the mix of white vinegar, Worcestershire sauce, molasses, cane sugar, garlic powder, raisins, and citrus flavors.

All the ingredients in 365 Steak Sauce are USDA certified organic making this a healthy alternative to many other steak sauces. 

Best Steak Sauce Brands

  1. Peter Luger Steak Sauce
  2. Lea & Perrins Bold Steak Sauce
  3. A-1 Steak Sauce
  4. Primal Kitchen Organic Steak Sauce and Marinade
  5. Country Bob’s All Purpose Sauce
  6. Delmonicos Classic 1837 Steak Sauce
  7. Heinz 57
  8. Shula’s Special No. 347
  9. HP Sauce
  10. London Pub, Sauce Steak & Chop
  11. Lea & Perrins Traditional Steak Sauce
  12. Crystal Steak Sauce
  13. 365 Whole Foods Organic Steak Sauce

Final Thoughts

Writing this list made me hungry for a perfectly grilled ribeye steak. 

While many steak sauces have a similar base and use ingredients like tomato, vinegar, or citrus, each item on this list has a distinct flavor. They all go great on steaks and burgers and complement most other dishes.

Whether you are barbecuing for the family or headed out for a full English breakfast, don’t forget to add one of these steak sauces to the meal. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Written by Erin Elizabeth

Erin is an editor and food writer who loves traveling and trying new foods and fun cocktails. Erin has been writing and editing professionally for 5 years since graduating from Temple University, and has been on the Restaurant Clicks team for 3 years. She has a long background working in the restaurant industry, and is an avid home chef and baker. Her favorite restaurants are those with spicy food and outdoor seating so that she can bring along her dog, Miss Piggy.