Woe be to ye who have never tried Jeni’s ice cream.
The people over at Jeni’s take their ice cream very seriously and curate every moment of the ice cream experience. Things like mouth feel, aftertaste, and creaminess are scientifically altered to create the genuinely perfect ice cream.
With such high standards, you might think that only a few flavors are available. And you’d be wrong!
Jeni’s has had hundreds of unique ice cream flavors over the years, from seasonal flavors and limited editions to flavors they can never take off the menu lest the public riot.
So many choices and so much ice cream. It can be impossible to choose just one flavor. However, some flavors stand out amongst the rest, delivering a unique, blissful experience that you can genuinely call ice cream.
Best Jeni’s Ice Cream Flavors
I always keep at least one pint of Jeni’s Ice Cream in my freezer in case of a dire sweet-tooth attack or heartache emergency. There’s nothing quite like it, and you should take this opportunity to go out and get your favorite flavor on this list.
Brown Butter Almond Brittle
You could describe this flavor as similar to a classic flavor – butter pecan. You can say that it is crunchy, smooth, gooey, and sweet. But at the end of the day, no matter what words you use to describe it, they will all fall short.
Brown Butter Almond Brittle is the my favorite flavor of Jeni’s Ice Cream. It’s nutty, sweet, crunchy, melty, and the perfect ice cream.
When you first take a bite, you accept the richness of the brown butter, which perfectly compliments the crunchy bits of sweet almond brittle.
Based upon a Norwegian dessert called krokan, Brown Butter Almond Brittle quickly became an official menu item once it was introduced.
Are you a fan of dark chocolate? Like, super dark chocolate?
Then this is the ice cream flavor for you.
Darkest Chocolate is exactly what it sounds like, a chocolate ice cream so dark that it barely passes the legal limits to be called ice cream.
Rich, smooth chocolate goodness that pours down your tongue and leaves you dreaming about it for days afterward.
Just be warned: no other chocolate ice cream will compare after you try this flavor.
If you eat chocolate ice cream from any other brand, you will be left with the memory of the dark chocolate flavor you genuinely desire.
No, this isn’t an ice cream shop that sells baked goods. This is an ice cream that sells ice cream that tastes precisely like baked goods but in ice cream format.
Brambleberry Crisp tastes exactly what it sounds like: a crisp made with several kinds of berries, eaten with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
The recipe includes jam made with blackberries and blackcurrants, with an oat streusel that softens a little in the rich vanilla ice cream, just like a regular crisp.
Every bite is a veritable shiver of delicious berry flavors, soft crumble, and melty ice cream.
If you love this flavor, try similar fruit flavors from Tillamook!
Salted Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks
Is there a more iconic flavor combination than peanut butter and chocolate?
There’s peanut butter and jelly, but I’m talking about the incomparable Salted Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks.
Peanut butter and chocolate are lovely, mainly when put together, but Jeni’s adds salt to the mix. The saltiness contrasts against the sweetness in a heavenly way, elevating the entire experience.
Moreover, this ice cream strikes a perfect balance between the peanut butter ice cream and the chocolate flecks.
It’s based on an iconic candy in Ohio, where Jeni’s is headquartered. So if you’re in the mood for a classic or want to try a truly incredible flavor, give this sweet and salty tribute to the Buckeye State a try.
Salty Caramel is one of Jeni’s mainstays and was an instant hit when first introduced.
This flavor isn’t like the other caramel ice creams you’ve tried: for one, the caramel is mixed with ice cream. No streaks of caramel that go through vanilla, the ice cream itself is caramel-flavored.
Salty isn’t a typo. They don’t mean “salted caramel.” This caramel is salty: saltier than most other salted caramels.
However, saltiness and sweetness play off each other in an ice cream flavor like no other. It’s incredible how much salt can work in a sweet dessert, but Jeni pulls it off with aplomb.
Most entries on this list are regulars on Jeni’s menu.
You can buy them anytime, anywhere, and enjoy them whenever possible. Supermoon isn’t one of them and is a discontinued flavor that we’re hoping returns someday.
When you first crack open the carton, you’d see the floral blue-violet ice cream making a crescent moon.
Then delicate blue-violet floral flavor is mixed with the sweet balance of vanilla, creating a harmony of fragile flavors within your mouth.
It’s like they gave moonbeams a taste and named it after a cosmic event that only happens once or twice a year.
Gooey Butter Cake
Before trying this flavor, you must ask yourself: do you like cake? If the answer is yes (as it should be), prepare for the melty, smooth, cakey flavor of Gooey Butter Cake.
This ice cream has bits of vanilla cake in it. As if that isn’t enough, the ice cream is cream cheese flavored and has a swirl of caramel-butterscotch sauce.
And the result of combining all of these is a rich, buttery flavor that melts in your mouth and swirls around like the best slice of cake you’ve ever had.
Best Jeni’s Ice Cream Flavors
- Brown Butter Almond Brittle
- Darkest Chocolate
- Brambleberry Crisp
- Salted Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks
- Salty Caramel
- Gooey Butter Cake
If these flavors don’t convince you, check out Jeni’s menu. They have so many flavors, like Sunshine, Watermelon Taffy, and Golden Nectar, that you’re sure to find one that fits your tastebuds.
When you buy Jeni’s Ice Cream, you’re paying for quality. Ice cream is sure to be good, from opening the carton to the satisfying aftertaste you get after finishing your dessert.
With so many quality flavors to choose from, you can eat Jeni’s for months and not try the same flavor twice.
But you’ll want to. If Jeni’s is known for one thing and one thing only, it’s ice cream that will keep you coming back for more.
Check out other ice cream brands we love!
This page may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we'll earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.