11 Best Seafood Restaurants in Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh is known for many things: its bridges, its sports teams, and its food. But when it comes to food, it’s common to overlook one of the types of cuisine that Pittsburgh really shines for: seafood.

friends eating at a seafood restaurant in pittsburgh

Whether you come for business or pleasure, expecting to take in more of a traditional comfort food fare, you simply cannot miss the seafood scene in the city. On my most recent trip, I prioritized finding where to get seafood in Pittsburgh to share with you what makes each one so unique. So buckle your seatbelts and prepare for your mouth to water. From fresh, grilled fish to fancy seafood pasta dishes, oysters, and a whole lot more, here are the best seafood restaurants in Pittsburgh to help you plan the culinary leg of your next trip.

1. Monterey Bay Fish Grotto

1411 Grandview Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15211
Phone: 412-481-4414
Visit Website

The Monterey Bay Fish Grotto
Source: Monterey Bay Fish Grotto

Located just across the Ohio River from Pittsburgh landmarks like Fort Duquesne and the Point State Park Fountain, this upscale seafood restaurant is the perfect place to make reservations for an elevated night of fine dining. The atmosphere is upscale but not stuffy, and the two-level restaurant has squeaky-clean glass walls that show off the beautiful views and all of the city lights at their finest. Monterey Bay Fish Grotto has won sustainability awards and focuses on sourcing local seafood and spirits, so you can truly get a taste of what Pittsburgh is all about. Their whole menu is teeming with fresh, rich seafood options and innovative takes on all your favorites. The surf n’ turf deviled eggs are a must, and for lovers of creole cuisine, the blackened shrimp and scallops etouffee is a flavorful option that has me planning my next trip back as we speak!

2. Luke Wholey’s Wild Alaskan Grille

2106 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Phone: 412-904-4509
Visit Website

The Luke Wholey’s Wild Alaskan Grille
Source: Luke Wholey’s Wild Alaskan Grille

Overlooking the Allegheny River in the historic Strip District, Luke Wholey’s Wild Alaskan Grille is a great place to enjoy a casual but still impeccable plate of incredible seafood inspired by the founder’s lifelong obsession with fishing. Closed on Monday and Tuesday, this grill is relaxed and comfortable, with ocean-life-inspired murals adorning the walls. Choose from a seasonal menu or sushi menu, including favorites like mussels and calamari for starters and a host of sandwiches, tacos, pastas, and creative entrees. In my opinion, the hand-breaded fish and chips are a masterful take on the classic that satisfies a longing for seafood and comfort food all in one.

See also  Where to Get the Freshest Seafood in St. Louis

3. Roland’s Seafood Grill

1904 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Phone: 412-261-3401
Visit Website

The Roland’s Seafood Grill
Source: Roland’s Seafood Grill

This restaurant is another gem in the historic Strip District. As a family-owned and operated joint, the atmosphere is light and hip. They’re one of the most popular Pittsburgh seafood restaurants, not to mention bar and lounge destinations. With pretty open hours, they’re a great place to hit for lunch while in the Strip District. Not only will you find lots of sports-inspired drink specials in support of local pro teams, but the menu offerings are winners, too, blending traditional Pittsburgh fare with Italian-inspired seafood. Try out the prosciutto-wrapped shrimp, sample from the raw bar, or try my favorite, Roland’s famous hot lobster roll.

4. Muddy Waters Oyster Bar

130 S Highland Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15206
Phone: 412-361-0555
Visit Website

The Muddy Waters Oyster Bar
Source: Muddy Waters Oyster Bar

If you didn’t guess by the name, the Muddy Waters Oyster Bar offers Louisiana seafood style with top-rate local seafood and provides a jazzy, bluesy atmosphere to enjoy it in. You’ll find them on South Highland Ave near Penn Ave. With an extensive drink menu as well as a separate oyster, brunch, and supper menu, this cool, classy spot is the perfect place to take in a slow-paced, French-inspired Sunday brunch—yes, even for seafood lovers! Try out the shrimp and grits, catfish sticks, or incredible lobster eggs benedict. And if brunch isn’t really your style, visit for dinner and try the jambalaya or gumbo or make a memory and order an alligator po’boy! While it’s not technically seafood, I think it still counts!

5. Penn Avenue Fish Co

2208 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Phone: 412-434-7200
Visit Website

The Penn Avenue Fish Co
Source: Penn Avenue Fish Co

This restaurant and fresh fish market is the place to go to sample Pittsburgh’s finest and freshest. Whether you go to enjoy a sit-down meal or order online for pickup, this fish market boasts some of the best sushi and fish-centered dishes. Just a few blocks from the Pittsburgh Opera, Penn Avenue Fish Co serves their lunch menu all day and has daily changing specials. Some of my favorites are the tuna salad sandwich, the yellowfin tuna teriyaki, and the south beach snapper. Seats here go quickly, so be sure to call ahead to make a reservation if you don’t decide to order out. Either way, there are plenty of super-fresh and Asian-inspired offerings to go around.

6. Mallorca Restaurant

2228 E Carson St, Pittsburgh, PA 15203
Phone: 412-488-1818
Visit Website

The Mallorca Restaurant
Source: Mallorca Restaurant

Visit Mallorca Restaurant near the Monongahela River on the South Side to take a trip back in time for an elevated dining experience centered on continental Spanish cuisine. With dining areas both indoors and out, Mallorca is an excellent pick for summertime when you want a little bit of luxury and a consummate wine list. You can’t do Mallorca and not try their incredible paella, one of the historically quintessential Spanish seafood dishes. Other luxurious dishes include the trout meuniere and the mariscada. Make sure to call ahead to check updates about their temporary operation hours and make a reservation.

See also  Where to Go for the Freshest Seafood in Seattle

7. McCormick & Schmick’s Seafood & Steaks

301 Fifth Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Phone: 412-201-6992
Visit Website

The McCormick & Schmick’s Seafood & Steaks
Source: McCormick & Schmick’s Seafood & Steaks

Although this is a chain restaurant with locations across the country, you’d never guess it. Their Piatt Place location on Fifth Avenue near the Embassy Suites is a luxury destination for exquisite seafood and steaks. They’re also involved in a sustainable fish program that helps to create a more environmentally friendly process from farm to table. This restaurant intentionally works to support and patronize local businesses. The salmon pesto and shrimp Pomodoro are fresh, inspired dishes at the top of my lunch list, while their classic entrees like shrimp scampi, fish n’ chips, and parmesan-crusted flounder definitely won’t disappoint. With both pickup and delivery also available, you have no excuse not to try their incredible offerings when you’re in the area.

8. Eddie V’s Prime Seafood

501 Grant St Suite 100, Pittsburgh, PA 15219
Phone: 412-391-1714
Visit Website

The McCormick & Schmick’s Seafood & Steaks
Source: McCormick & Schmick’s Seafood & Steaks

On the corner of Grant Street and Fifth Avenue, Eddie V’s is a stylish, cool downtown destination in the Union Trust Building conveniently situated between the three rivers. You’ll have an elevated, luxurious dining experience on location, but Eddie V’s also hand-cuts steak and seafood for purchase to cook at home as well so you can take the experience with you. Seafood is the name of the game at this prime eatery, including an impressive selection of oysters and Petrossian caviar. The Georges bank scallops are a citrusy and indulgent delight, while the Mediterranean branzino takes you straight to the coast.

9. Dorido’s Restaurant

6408 Brownsville Rd, Pittsburgh, PA 15236
Phone: 412-655-4711
Visit Website

The Dorido’s Restaurant
Source: Dorido’s Restaurant

Open daily on Brownsville Road right by the South Park Golf Course, Dorido’s offers peel and eat, fresh catch of the day, and down-to-earth entrees that are satisfying takes on the classics you know and love. Make sure to visit on a Friday to take advantage of their specials, including a list of seafood-forward soups, freshly caught fish, and specially priced seafood appetizers. With fish n’ chips, crab cakes, cajun catfish, and a host of bar-style offerings, Dorido’s is the perfect place to try out if you’re not feeling anything too fancy but still want quality, memorable fresh seafood.

10. Eddie Merlot’s Prime Aged Beef & Seafood Pittsburgh

Four Gateway Center, 444 Liberty Ave #100, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
Phone: 412-235-7676
Visit Website

The Eddie Merlot’s Prime Aged Beef & Seafood Pittsburgh
Source: Eddie Merlot’s Prime Aged Beef & Seafood Pittsburgh

Located at the Four Gateway Center at the corner of Liberty Avenue and Stanwix Street, this top-of-the-line steak and seafood house offers happy hour and lounge hour throughout the week, with private dining available. A dinner reservation is the best way to take in the luxurious atmosphere and all of the elevated dinner menu offerings. I can’t resist their charcuterie on the starter menu, and their cedar plank salmon is to die for! For seafood lovers who have steak lovers in tow, this place is the perfect compromise. All beef is aged at least 21 days, and Eddie Merlot’s is the only establishment in the U.S. to offer Australian-raised Wagyu beef. Just trust me, you won’t regret visiting.

See also  Discovering the Delights of Kani: A Guide to this Exquisite Seafood Delicacy

11. Merchant Oyster Co.

4129 Butler St, Pittsburgh, PA 15201
Phone: 412-932-2553
Visit Website

The Merchant Oyster Co.
Source: Merchant Oyster Co.

Located on Butler Street near Arsenal Park, Merchant Oyster Co. satisfies your needs for a hip, cool oyster bar with northeastern-style fare and chowder that’s out of this world. There’s plenty to enjoy in the casual, laid-back environment. While their hours of operation are subject to change weekly, their website stays up to date with everything you need to know to make sure you can fit this great spot into your next trip. There are, of course, tons of oyster options to choose from, from on the half shelf to baked, from stuffed to shooters – they’ve got it all. If you decide to venture outside the oyster menu, try out their crab mac n’ cheese, one of their four styles of chowder, or their Cuban lobster panini. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Written by Brian Nagele

Brian attended West Virginia University, then started his career in the IT industry before following his passion for marketing and hospitality. He has over 20 years experience in the restaurant and bar industry.

As a former restaurant owner, he knows about running a food business and loves to eat and enjoy cocktails on a regular basis. He constantly travels to new cities tasting and reviewing the most popular spots.

Follow him on LinkedIn, Instagram, Quora, Google Guide and Facebook.