Erin Elizabeth
A good slice of pie is comforting, tasty, and paired well with a cup of tea or coffee. The best pie shops in America offer some amazing slices!
The great thing about pie is that you can enjoy it any day of the year. There are refreshing pies that hit the spot in the summer, and cozy pies that warm you from the inside in the winter.
Pies come in all shapes and sizes. From breakfast hand pies to large meringue-covered pies to individually-sied fruit pies, you will indeed find a pie for every situation and mood.
No matter its form, pie is always my favorite dessert and sometimes my favorite savory meal or snack.
When finding the best pies, I look for a few variables. I love pie that reflects fresh, seasonal ingredients and comes from a team or a person that is passionate about what they do.
Best Pie Shops in America
Keep reading to discover the best pie shops in America that you simply have to try.
Sister Pie
8066 Kercheval Ave, Detroit, MI 48214
Phone: 313-447-5550
Visit Website
Sister Pie is a Detroit, Michigan staple that became a brick-and-mortar store in 2015 after Lisa Ludwinski started the bakery in 2012 from her parents’ kitchen.
The bakery produces pastries and pies inspired by seasonal and local ingredients.
The bakery offers items on a first-come, first-served basis. However, you can pre-order items at Sister Pie’s online shop. Beyond pre-made baked goods, you can also pick up groceries from this bakery.
It also offers fun classes where you can learn how to bake your desserts.
I love trying this bakery’s rotating offerings. In particular, I adore the savory hand pies and the salted maple pie.
A La Mode Pies
5821 Phinney Ave N, Seattle, WA 98103
Phone: 206-383-3796
Visit Website
A La Mode Pies is a Seattle, Washington pie shop with three locations that started in 2009.
The bakery has a rotating sweet and savory pie menu that changes with the seasons and has pies, quiche, cheesecakes, and tarts.
The bakery also offers pie-making classes and desserts for events, including weddings.
While you can find daily offerings at the bakery, you can also order a whole pie from the bakery with its order-ahead menu.
If you live locally, you can get delivery or pick-up. The fruit tart is always a refreshing bite, and I love seeing how the fruits change with the seasons.
I also adore the blue Hawaiian pie and the french apple pie.
Dahlia Bakery
2001 4th Ave, Seattle, WA 98121
Phone: 206-441-4540
Visit Website
Visit Dahlia Bakery if you want a cozy Seattle, Washington bakery where you can find pastries, breakfast, lunch, and, of course, pie.
This bakery is particularly famous for its world-famous triple coconut cream pie. It also offers gorgeous tarts and cheesecakes.
You can order online from the bakery for pick-up and delivery. If you would like a pie for a special reason, you can preorder.
Like many, I am a triple coconut cream pie fan. I also am partial to the pistachio blood orange tart and the strawberry pink peppercorn cheesecake.
Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits
2051 N California Ave, Chicago, IL 60647
Phone: 773-276-8888
Visit Website
Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits is a popular bakery in Chicago, Illinois. In addition to its pies, Bang Bang is known for its biscuits, cookies, grits, quiche, and other items.
This bakery offers delicious catering options, and you can find their items at several shops and restaurants around the city.
If you are in Chicago, you can order items for pick-up and delivery. While the bakery does not ship prepared dishes, they mail shelf-stable items, such as biscuit mix, granola, coffee, jam, hot cocoa mix, and gravy spice.
My favorites at this pie shop are almost too many to count. I adore their banana cream pie, strawberry rhubarb pie, and southern tomato pot pie.
Honeypie
2569 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Phone: 414-489-7437
Visit Website
Founded in 2009, Honeypie is a Milwaukee, Wisconsin-based pie shop and cafe.
At the cafe, get breakfast, lunch, brunch, dinner, and drinks. The pie shop offers pies and pie-making lessons. They also have a pie of the month club.
Honeypie operates on a first-come, first-serve basis. If you want to order a whole pie, you can do so via phone or online.
You should provide at least 48 hours for a special order pie. If you need to pick up a pie within a day, some limited pies are available.
I always love trying Honeypie’s pie of the month. However, my go-to’s include blueberry lemonade pie, cherry hand pies, and Milwaukee mud pie.
Texas Pie Company
202 W Center St, Kyle, TX 78640
Phone: 512-268-5885
Visit Website
Texas Pie Company is a pie shop and restaurant in Kyle, Texas.
While this restaurant is primarily known for its pies, it also offers cakes and main dishes.
The bakery chef, Julie Albertson, opened her first bakery in 1986.
If you live near the restaurant, you can order pies for pick-up. However, you do not need to travel to Texas to enjoy Texas Pie Company’s pies.
This bakery offers pie delivery throughout the United States. I love trying this bakery’s unique offerings, including fudge pecan, coconut macaroon, and strawberry peach.
Dangerously Delicious Pies
2839 O’Donnell St, Baltimore, MD 21224
Phone: 410-522-7437
Visit Website
Dangerously Delicious Pies is a unique pie shop in Baltimore, Maryland.
They are known for their handmade pies made without additives and preservatives. The bakery offers sweet pies, savory pies, and quiches.
If you are in the Baltimore area, you can order the pies for pickup or delivery. You can even visit their test kitchen location!
Those living in other parts of the United States can get the pies shipped. If you order pies ahead for pickup, follow the heating directions that come with the pie.
My favorites from this pie shop include the pancake pies, the full custom custard, the pineapple right-side-up pie, and the toffee crunch pie.
I Like Pie Bake Shop
175 N Indian Hill Blvd #102b, Claremont, CA 91711
Phone: 909-621-5152
Visit Website
I Like Pie Bake Shop is an adorable bakery in Claremont, California. In addition to pie, this bakery is known for its coffee and ice cream.
The pies here are unique because they are individually sized. The sweet and savory pies make a fantastic meal or snack at any point of the day.
The flavors can change depending on the season and ingredient availability.
You can order pies for delivery or pickup if you are in the Claremont area. I always love seeing the seasonal selections.
Some of my favorites include the bananas foster, strawberry shortcake, and cookie butter pie. I also enjoy their savory pies, including the chicken pot pie.
Pie Junkie
1711 NW 16th St, Oklahoma City, OK 73106
Phone: 405-605-8767
Visit Website
If you are craving pie in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, you must check out Pie Junkie.
This spot is great because you can find cozy favorites and innovative flavors. Pie Junkie opened the doors to its permanent location in 2013. It offers whole pies, pie by the slice, and take and bake meals.
You can order whole pies for pickup over the phone or online if you are local. Make sure to provide 48 hours of advance notice.
My favorites at Pie Junkie include the veggie ale pot pie, the southern banana cream pie, bird dog buttermilk pie, and frozen strawberry lemonade pretzel pie.
Four & Twenty Blackbirds
439 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Phone: 718-499-2917
Visit Website
Four & Twenty Blackbirds is a pie shop in New York City.
The bakery was founded by sisters Melissa and Emily Elsen in 2009. They focus on creating pies using fresh seasonal and local ingredients.
You can order pies from this pie shop for local pickup and delivery. You can also order the pies to ship nationwide.
This bakery also offers pies for special events and wholesale needs.
My absolute favorite pie here is the salty honey pie, but I also adore the lemon chess pie, coffee custard, matcha custard, and black bottom oat.
P is for Pie Bake Shop
2806 Corrine Dr, Orlando, FL 32803
Phone: 407-745-4743
Visit Website
P is for Pie Bake Shop is a little spot that uses seasonal ingredients in its sweet pies, savory pies, cakes, cookies, and cinnamon rolls in Orlando, Florida.
The exact offerings frequently change, depending on the seasons.
Since this pie shop is so small, ordering your pies in advance is always a good idea. Make sure to order your pie at least 72 hours in advance.
For larger orders or orders of pie pops, you may need more time. Orders need to be placed in person or on the phone.
Some of my favorite items at this bakery include the breakfast hand pies, southern pecan pie, salted honey bourbon mini pies, and salted honey lavender hand pies.
Petee’s Pie Company
61 Delancey St, New York, NY 10002
Phone: 646-494-3630
Visit Website
Petee’s Pie Company is known for its classic and innovative flavored pies alike.
It is one of the most popular pie shops in New York City. The bakery makes pies with local produce and other ingredients.
Besides the sweet and savory pies, you can also get ice cream, alcohol, and groceries.
This bakery offers pickup, delivery, and takeout from its two locations. I love the coconut custard, brown butter honey pecan, key lime meringue, and wild blueberry crumb pies.
Petsi Pies
285 Beacon St, Somerville, MA 02143
Phone: 617-661-7437
Visit Website
Choose from a delicious list of cookies, cupcakes, and sweet and savory pies at this Somerville, Massachusetts pie shop.
Founded in 2003, Petsi Pie uses natural ingredients fresh every day. You can enjoy coffee and pastries at the bakery and coffee bar in addition to pies.
You can get an order delivered if you live within a four-mile radius of the bakery, you can get an order delivered.
Petsi Pie also provides pies for weddings. I adore the peach blackberry pie, bacon corn and jalapeno pie, fresh mozzarella tomato and basil pie, and brown butter pecan pie.
Best Pie Shops in America
- Sister Pie
- A la Mode Pies
- Dahlia Bakery
- Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits
- Honeypie
- Texas Pie Company
- Dangerously Delicious Pies
- I Like Pie Bake Shop
- Pie Junkie
- Four & Twenty Blackbirds
- P is for Pie Bake Shop
- Petee’s Pie Company
- Petsi Pies
Final Thoughts
Now that you know where to find the best pie shops in America, it is time to find the closest one to you and find out how amazing they are for you.
In a few cases, you can even get pie shipped to you, no matter where you live in the country.
So, whether you prefer sweet or savory, fruit or cream pies, there is no excuse not to have fantastic pie in your life.
If you love sweets but you’re not a pie person, check out the best bakeries in the US instead!
