Flagstaff Pizza Restaurants You Have to Try

With Flagstaff being such a popular spot to visit for the weekend, you can expect this town to have quite a few restaurant options. We can definitely all agree that one of the best parts of taking a vacation is not having to cook.

Who doesn’t love going out to a restaurant and not having to worry about any of the details? With all of this said, it can still be nice to have a night in – even while on a vacation.

People eating pizza in Flagstaff

So, what’s the perfect meal to grab for a cozy night in the hotel? Pizza of course!

With so many places to choose from, you may feel overwhelmed. But don’t worry, we’ve got you.

Keep reading to find out what our favorite pizza joints are in Flagstaff!

NiMarco’s Pizza

1800 S Milton Rd, Flagstaff, AZ 86001
Phone: (928) 779-0024
Visit Website

With three different locations, in downtown Flagstaff, the eastside, and the westside, Nimarco’s is a popular pizza stop for many locals.

Run by locals of the town and NAU alumni, grabbing some pizza at this restaurant is a great way to support a local business.

Nimarco’s makes their sauce and dough in-house daily, so you’ll be sure to have only the freshest pizza here. Also, with a long list of choices, this restaurant is bound to have a pizza you’ll love.

Be sure to try out the Gary’s Special, it’s a local favorite. And if you have allergies, Nimarco’s offers gluten-free and vegan options!


203 W Phoenix Ave, Flagstaff, AZ 86001
Phone: (928) 774-3242
Visit Website

Looking for some pizza that you can pickup in a snap? Try out Pizzicletta.

This spot is located in downtown Flagstaff, so it’s a great place to grab some food if you’re looking to explore the shops after you eat.

Serving wood-fired pizzas that cook in less than two minutes, it’s no wonder why this restaurant has glowing reviews. Specifically, many locals praise Pizzicletta for the top-notch service and amazing pizza, of course.

Try out the SS-145 or rucola pizzas for an extraordinary pizza experience. And don’t forget to grab some gelato for dessert!

Your Pie Pizza

2619 S Woodlands Village Blvd Suite #650, Flagstaff, AZ 86001
Phone: (928) 440-5500
Visit Website

How does a fully customizable pizza place sound? Everything you’ve ever dreamed of? Check out Your Pie Pizza.

See also  Domino's Gives Away Free Emergency Pizzas

Your Pie is another great option for quick pizza, but with the bonus of adding what you like, and avoiding what you don’t. This place is set up like a salad bar, so you get to pick your dough, sauce, toppings, and finishers.

With vegan, vegetarian, gluten-free, and even keto options, this stop will have something for almost everyone. Be sure to try out the southern heat pizza for that Arizona experience.

Don’t forget the gelato or 32 oz. beer or wine!

Fratelli Pizza

119 W Phoenix Ave, Flagstaff, AZ 86001
Phone: (928) 774-9200
Visit Website

Another local pizza shop with three locations around the town is Fratelli Pizza. Specifically, Fratelli has locations in downtown Flag, on the eastside, and in Fort Valley.

This restaurant uses house made dough and prioritizes the freshness of their ingredients, so you know it’ll be a great pizza.

With a large menu full of pizza options, including pan pizzas and a gluten-free crust, Fratelli aims to please almost every palate.

And if you’re not in the mood for pizza, Fratelli has other options like calzones, salads, and more.

Be sure to try out the Chicago pan pizza or build your own!

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria

601 E Piccadilly Dr Suite 55, Flagstaff, AZ 86001
Phone: (928) 774-9038
Visit Website

Located just outside of downtown Flagstaff, Grimaldi’s Pizzeria is a stop you won’t want to miss.

With a spacious patio, you’ll be able to enjoy delicious pizza while also taking in the beautiful views surrounding the area.

This restaurant makes all of its pizzas in a coal brick oven, to ensure they’re as tasty as possible. With traditional pizzas, specialty pizzas, a gluten-free crust, and a cauliflower crust, this spot has it all.

Be sure to try out the bacon and asparagus pizza with spicy honey or the garden pesto pizza!

The Pizza Patio

109 E Phoenix Ave, Flagstaff, AZ 86001
Phone: (928) 779-4000
Visit Website

Looking for a pizza restaurant with a versatile menu? Take a look at The Pizza Patio.

Located in downtown Flagstaff, this restaurant is a great place to grab a bite and enjoy weather while sitting by the fire pit on their patio.

With an abundance of vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, Pizza Patio won’t let anyone’s taste buds down.

This spot has traditional pizzas as well as creative ones you’ve probably never heard of like the curse of the billy goat or mafia chicken alfredo.

See also  Times Square Pizza Spots for Your Next NYC Visit

Don’t forget to try the cauliflower wings, pretzel bites, or mac n cheese bites!

Famous Pizza & Beer

104 East E Rte 66, Flagstaff, AZ 86001
Phone: (928) 440-5286
Visit Website

In the mood for pizza and some great beer? Look no further than Famous Pizza & Beer.

This locally owned restaurant is praised for its great service, tasty pizza, and cold, refreshing beers. With two other locations in Sedona, it’s clear this one is a can’t miss in Northern Arizona.

Famous Pizza & Beer serves East Coast style pizzas, wings, and subs, so you definitely won’t be leaving hungry.

Try out the buddha beach or whitestone spinach pizza while you’re there. And don’t forget to sip on a beer too!

New Jersey Pizza Co.

2224 E Cedar Ave #6, Flagstaff, AZ 86004
Phone: (928) 774-5000
Visit Website

A lesser known, but highly-rated pizza stop in Flagstaff is New Jersey Pizza Co. This spot is located close to downtown, so it’s not far from other attractions in the town.

New Jersey Pizza Co. receives all of their ingredients from authentic and premium sources and also uses house-made ingredients to ensure the best tasting pizza you can imagine.

With a long list of pizza choices, vegan, and gluten-free options, this place is great for big groups who may have different tastes. They also offer calzones and hummus.

Be sure to try the combo or the award-winning steamy V pizzas!

Pizza Edge

7810 N, US-89 Suite 220, Flagstaff, AZ 86004
Phone: (928) 522-5900
Visit Website

Another top spot for pizza in Flagstaff is Pizza Edge. Located on Highway 89, this is a great place to stop on your way in or out of town.

If you’re looking for a more traditional pizza menu, Pizza Edge will definitely satisfy your pizza craving.

With pizzas, wings, breadsticks, salads, and more, you’ll certainly find something to your liking here.

Don’t forget to try the famous breadsticks and cinistix with homemade cream cheese frosting!

Fat Olives

2308 E Rte 66, Flagstaff, AZ 86004
Phone: (928) 853-0056
Visit Website

Finishing out our list for the best pizza in Flagstaff is Fat Olives, of course. This stop even has VPN (Verace Pizza Napoletana) certified pizzas.

See also  All There is to Know About Tavern-Style Pizza

This pizzeria and Italian restaurant makes all of their pizzas in a wood-fired oven with only the best imported ingredients to ensure that your pizza is completely satisfactory.

With pizza, pasta, and other menu items, this is definitely a must-try while in town. They even offer several gluten-free options.

Be sure to stop by between 2 p.m. to 5 p.m. daily for happy hour!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Written by Tess Stafford

Tess Stafford is an undergraduate at Northern Arizona University studying journalism. She grew up in Phoenix and now lives in Flagstaff. Tess enjoys eating out with friends or family frequently and is always on the lookout for restaurants with gluten-free options!