Where to Get the Perfect Slice of Pizza in Columbus

Though there’s no denying Columbus is full of tasty restaurants, sometimes all you want is a delicious pizza. I don’t know about you, but some nights this well-loved dish is the only thing that can satisfy my hunger.

group of happy friends eating pizza in columbus

From a buttery crust, to a tangy sauce, and gooey cheese, there’s so much to love about pizza. And if one thing is for sure, it’s that we all prefer our pizza a little bit different.

I’ve put together a list of my favorite pizza spots in town so you can find the right one for you.

From thin crust to thick crust and classic pies to creative ones, everyone will find a place to fix their cravings.

With sit-down restaurants and pizzerias selling their pies by the slice, there’s also a spot for every occasion. Keep reading to learn more about each restaurant!

Borgata Pizza Cafe

5701 Parkville St, Columbus, OH 43229
Phone: (614) 891-2345
Visit Website

Borgata Pizza Cafe
Source: Borgata Pizza Cafe

If you like New York style pizza, you’re going to love Borgata Pizza Cafe. This local restaurant serves up pizza and pasta just like the East Coast city.

With hundreds of reviews about the food and service, it’s no wonder people love this spot.

There’s plenty to choose from on Borgata Pizza Cafe’s menu, but the pizza is the star of the show here, of course.

We recommend the pesto chicken, margherita, supreme, or Mediterranean roasted vegetable. They also sell their pies by the slice for when you want a quick meal!

Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza

1618 Neil Ave, Columbus, OH 43201
Phone: (614) 421-2300
Visit Website

Adriatico's New York Style Pizza
Source: Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza

Similar to the previous spot on the list, Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza is perfect for thin crust lovers.

With pizza, pasta, sandwiches, and more alongside beer and wine, you’ll find everything you need at this spot.

Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza offers build-your-own varieties in addition to specialty pizzas.

Be sure to try the chicken bacon ranch, inflation fighter, buffalo chicken, or chicken pesto. Don’t forget to sip on a beer or glass of wine with your pizza!

Plank’s Cafe & Pizzeria

743 Parsons Ave, Columbus, OH 43206
Phone: (614) 445-7221
Visit Website

Plank's Cafe & Pizzeria
Source: Plank’s Cafe & Pizzeria

Though a bit lesser known than the other spots on this list, Plank’s Cafe & Pizzeria is one of the tastiest pizza places in town. It’s only a short walk from Parsons North Brewing Company, so you can grab some pizza after you’ve had a few local beers!

With a 4.6 star rating on Google, it’s clear that people really love this spot. Specifically, reviewers appreciate the large portions and attentive staff.

You’ll find a great selection of pizza varieties at Plank’s Cafe & Pizzeria. Try out the hot stuff, turkey tom, all the way, or white pizza.

Make sure to swing by in the morning to try their breakfast menu some time!

OH Pizza & Brew

88 E Broad St, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: (614) 940-8687
Visit Website

OH Pizza & Brew
Source: OH Pizza & Brew

Claiming to serve the best pizza and Italian food in Columbus, OH Pizza & Brew should be another addition to your list of restaurants to try.

And with hundreds of great reviews and late night hours, it make sense this spot is rated so highly.

The pizzas at OH Pizza & Brew are topped with unique ingredients and are even available gluten free.

We recommend the kaua’i pizza, buckeye garlic pizza, Mediterranean pizza, or Hattie-B’s pizza. Be sure to taste one of their deep-fried desserts!

Dewey’s Pizza

1327 W 5th Ave, Columbus, OH 43212
Phone: (614) 487-8282
Visit Website

Dewey's Pizza
Source: Dewey’s Pizza

If you like beer with your pizza, you’ll definitely want to visit Dewey’s Pizza next time you’re in town. This regional chain serves inventive pizzas alongside seasonal craft brews.

With hundreds of positive reviews, it’s no wonder so many people consider this spot their go-to pizza place.

The menu at Dewey’s Pizza is unlike any other, so you may have to visit a few times to try it all.

Be sure to try the porky fig, Dr. Dre, green lantern, or backyard BBQ. You can also build your own pizza or calzone!

Tommy’s Pizza

174 W Lane Ave, Columbus, OH 43201
Phone: (614) 294-4669
Visit Website

Tommy's Pizza
Source: Tommy’s Pizza

Established in 1952, Tommy’s Pizza has been a fan favorite for years now, with locations near the Ohio State University.

Serving Italian entrees and pizza with a unique cracker crust, this is the perfect place to fix your craving. People love the great service and crispy crust here.

The pizza section at Tommy’s is pretty straightforward with two signature pizzas and a build your own option. Choose from a wide list of toppings and sizes from a single slice to a large pie!

GoreMade Pizza

936 N 4th St, Columbus, OH 43201
Phone: (614) 725-2115
Visit Website

GoreMade Pizza
Source: GoreMade Pizza

If wood-fired pies are your favorite, we suggest trying GoreMade Pizza.

This local restaurant serves pizza made from locally-sourced ingredients, so you can feel good about eating at this spot.

GoreMade Pizza offers 12 inch pizzas, half-sized pizza boats, and gluten-free pizzas. We recommend the Annie social, porkistopheles, clintonvillain, or a custom pie.

Be sure to grab some of the house ice cream for dessert and sip on a cocktail or some wine with your meal!

Panzera’s Pizza

1354 Grandview Ave, Columbus, OH 43212
Phone: (614) 486-5951
Visit Website

Panzera's Pizza
Source: Panzera’s Pizza

Calling all thin-crust pizza lovers! Panzera’s Pizza is going to be your new favorite.

In business for more than five decades, this restaurant serves pizza in addition to other Italian favorites. Will special attention on the thin, crispy crust, you can count on these pies being top-notch.

Choose from several specialty pizzas or a customizable option at Panera’s Pizza.

Be sure to try the crowd pleaser, Freddy special, crazy all the way, or butcher block. Don’t forget to grab a beer or two to go with your pizza!

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus

1551 Lennox Town Ln, Columbus, OH 43212
Phone: (614) 928-9361
Visit Website

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus
Source: Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus

With a 4.5 star rating, Brenz Pizza Co. is clearly a popular choice for pizza in Columbus. This restaurant serves amazing pizzas in addition to subs, salads, and more.

People love the tasty food and good service.

Brenz Pizza Co. offers gluten-free pizza in addition to regular pizzas, which come in four different sizes. Try out the BBQ chicken, Brenz white, Bianca rossa, or spinach artichoke.

Make sure to grab some cookies or cinnabrenz to end your meal on a sweet note!

Sarefino’s Pizzeria & Italian Deli

59 Spruce St, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: (614) 228-2850
Visit Website

Sarefino's Pizzeria & Italian Deli
Source: Sarefino’s Pizzeria & Italian Deli

Completing our list of pizza restaurants is Sarefino’s Pizzeria & Italian Deli.

This local spot serves New York style pizza by the pie and by the slice, so whether you need a whole meal or a quick bite, this is the place to go.

The pizza section on Sarefino’s Pizzeria & Italian Deli’s menu is fairly modest, but just as delicious. We recommend the meathead, Greek, veggie, or pesto chicken.

Be sure to check out their pizza making kit for only $14.99!

Pizza is one of those things you just can’t go wrong with, and there’s so many different ways to make and enjoy it. As you may have noticed, Columbus exemplifies this easily. So the next time you’re craving pizza, you’ll know exactly where to go.

Looking for other great places to eat in the area? Check out our list of the best brunch restaurants in Columbus.

Which pizza are you most excited to try? Let us know! Did we leave a restaurant out of this list? Make sure you mention it below and we’ll check it out!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Written by Kyle Green

Kyle lives never passes up the opportunity to try a new restaurant. As a former New Yorker of 7 years, he enjoys regular trips to NYC to visit friends and enjoys all the restaurants and activities the city have to offer. He also spends time on the road tasting and reviewing other restaurant scenes around the country.