Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn, is known for its strong Italian-American roots and many shops and eateries in the area remain sparingly connected to Italian tradition. Recognizable New York Brownstones line the streets and many young professionals have moved to this part of Brooklyn.
From craft beer to a Shakespeare in the Park, this neighborhood in Brooklyn is a lovely place to visit. If you are searching for some of the best sushi in the area, look no further than our list of the eleven best restaurants in Carroll Gardens to enjoy sushi, sashimi, and sake!
We’ve ranked the absolute top rated sushi spots Carroll Gardens has to offer right here for you to check out. You’ll never wonder where to get sushi in Carroll Gardens again once you take a look at what we’ve got for.
Best Sushi in Carroll Gardens
- Daigo Sushi Roll Bar
- Saketumi Asian Bistro
- Koto Sushi
- Kumo Sushi II + Poké Bowl
- Sushi Lin
- Za-Ya Ramen
- Rice & Miso
- KI SUSHI
Daigo Sushi Roll Bar
527 Carroll St, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Daigo serves hand rolls and sushi rolls near the Union Street metro stop. The setting is cozy with bar seating and a vibrant blue carpet. The packaging is particularly good for takeout sushi, so Daigo is a perfect place to order from. if you are hosting dinner or a party. The restaurant is open from noon to 9:00 pm daily and offers a lunch special with either two or three rolls.
I started my meal with the miso soup then ordered a few rolls. The salmon and tuna are incredibly fresh. The Snow Crab Avocado cut roll and the Spicy Tuna hand roll are popular menu items. The crispy Eel Avocado hand roll was one of my favorite bites. Don’t skip on the poke bowl!
Saketumi Asian Bistro
118 Montague St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
Saketumi Asian Bistro is located in a cool building with a patio. The restaurant is open for lunch and dinner. The lunch special is two rolls for about fifteen dollars. What’s great about the sushi is that it is simple and done very well. Saketumi is within walking distance from the Court Street metro.
I enjoyed the shrimp pad Thai and the sashimi appetizer. The salmon teriyaki bento box is a great choice for the indecisive. I would also recommend the spider roll, the pineapple fried rice, and the Manhattan classic roll.
270 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Osaka is near the Bergen Street metro stop in Carroll Gardens. The outdoor garden area is beautiful and transports guests. The interior of the restaurant has exposed brick walls and black linen topped tables. Osaka is open daily for lunch and dinner. The service is outstanding.
I enjoyed the Philadelphia roll and the Rainbow roll, but the sushi menu is extensive. I would recommend the lobster tempura roll, the yellowtail sashimi, and the vegetable tempura entree. The kitchen’s plating of all of the dishes is beautiful and appetizing. Osaka is a great spot for sushi in the neighborhood.
552 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Koto Sushi offers a comfortable vibe in a contemporary setting. The restaurant is open Tuesday through Sunday for lunch and dinner. Guests can dine-in, order takeout, or call for delivery. It is a neighborhood stable and many people visit for a date night or to catch up with friends.
The pork gyoza is one of the most popular menu items. The restaurant offers dozens of special Maki roll options, I enjoyed the Snow White roll with white tuna and the Out of Control roll that is spicy and includes chili pepper and yellowtail. Try the banana tempura with ice cream for dessert!
Kumo Sushi II + Poké Bowl
512 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Kumo Sushi II serves authentic Japanese cuisine. The restaurant is open between Monday and Saturday. The vibe is excellent and on a nice day be sure to check out the back patio. The eatery is right beside the B57 bus stop on Court Street at Nelson Street. The bento box lunch is a guest favorite!
The build your own poke bowl menu is interactive and fun. You can also create your own sushi burrito! I was able to circle ingredients directly on a menu; my poke bowl was delicious and included salmon and yellowtail, cucumber, edamame, citrus ponzu sauce, pickled ginger, and onion crisps.
115 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
Kyoto is situated on the corner of Smith Street and Pacific Street in Carroll Gardens. Large white letters atop a bright orange background spelling in the restaurant name let’s you know that you’ve made it. Kyoto is open at noon daily and serves late-night sushi until 11:00 pm or after. There are plenty of vegetarian options and small plates.
When I visited Kyoto, I enjoyed the lunch special with two rolls for only eleven dollars! Try the Boston roll and the Peanut Avocado roll. I would also recommend the Tonkatsu box served with a California roll and soup. The Yankee roll with lobster and shrimp is also popular!
335 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Sushi Lin is open from 5:00 pm to 9:00 pm between Tuesday and Sunday. The eatery offers a daily chef’s choice menu and serves traditional Japanese dishes in a cozy, narrow space. The omakase at Sushi Lin is delicious and well worth sampling the next time you visit.
I first tried the tempura appetizer, which was delightful, then ate the spicy salmon hand roll and the yellowtail scallion Maki roll, both were great! I would also recommend the shrimp teriyaki or the pan-fried gyoza. The various menu combinations of sushi are excellent and can be cost-effective, especially if you enjoy sushi as much as I do.
545 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Za-Ya Ramen is a contemporary eatery serving a fresh take on ramen and other creative dishes. The restaurant is open daily with extended hours on the weekend. The classy exterior with a black awning sets the tone for a lovely meal, and the interior is light and welcoming. The B57 bus stop at Hamilton Avenue will drop you off right in front of the shop.
Try the Tuna Avocado with Sashimi tuna, avocado, sweet onions, and sesame-soy dressing. The restaurant’s signature dish is the Gyukotsu ramen, a Beef bone marrow broth topped with braised short rib beef, scallions, sweet onions, bamboo shoots, and garlic chips. The eatery offers a kid’s menu as well, so you can bring the entire family!
333 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
Hibino is situated on the border of the Carroll Gardens and Brooklyn Heights neighborhoods. The wood sushi bar creates a welcoming atmosphere for guests. The restaurant is open from Monday to Saturday for lunch and dinner.
Hibino offers housemade tofu that is served with ginger and scallions! Also, I enjoyed the beef kakuni and the miso soup. The sushi menu is filled with great options like the yellowtail jalapeno roll and the spicy scallop roll. The kitchen plates the sushi on long wooden boards which creates a family-style serving environment.
Rise & Miso
134 Nevins St, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Rise & Miso offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery foods and the restaurant specializes in unique rice balls! It is open for lunch and dinner from Monday to Saturday. The eatery identifies as women-owned. The Barclay’s Center is less than a half-mile from Rice & Miso.
When I visited the restaurant, I enjoyed the signature tuna mayo rice ball with albacore tuna. I would also recommend the sockeye salmon bento box and the kenchin soup. Plan to try one of the eight variations of rice balls on the menu and look out for specials on the restaurant’s social media pages!
122 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
Ki Sushi has a sleek exterior and an interior that offers a high-end feel. The restaurant is open daily for lunch and dinner. The chef specializes in omakase. The eatery strives to provide a relaxed atmosphere with excellent service. The kitchen plates the cuisine with precision and skill.
I enjoyed the manguro avocado with diced tuna and the eggplant miso. I would also recommend the king crab California roll and the salmon skin roll. The dragon roll is topped with roe and is perfectly delicious, and don’t skip the unique peach roll with tuna and topped with sliced peaches. The specialty rolls list goes on and on so visitors can be sure to find something to enjoy!
Carroll Gardens is a lovely and lively neighborhood in Brooklyn with a strong culture and a variety of delicious eateries and bars. The neighborhood is perfect for young professionals or new families and the restaurant scene caters to that population of people.
From sitting down to a crafted omakase meal to finding kid-friendly ramen to building your own poke bowl, the Japanese restaurants in the area are some of the best sushi spots in all of Brooklyn.
Not in the mood for sushi? Check out some great boozy brunch spots around Brooklyn!
Did we leave a restaurant out of this list? Make sure you leave us a comment and we’ll check it out!
This page may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we'll earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.