Many people flock to Marco Island for vacations and to move there full-time because of all the natural beauty of the area and all of the fun outdoor activities.
The waters are absolutely crystal clear and the beaches are immaculate, so it’s no surprise as to why everyone loves it down here.
One thing that I found even more enjoyable than all of the boating, fishing, and golfing opportunities was going out to eat, however, especially for seafood.
You really won’t find many other cities with access to such fresh seafood so expertly prepared in restaurants of this quality.
If that’s something that interests you as well, then just keep on reading.
I made it my mission to find out where to go in Marco Island for the absolute best seafood, and then I put together a list ranking all my favorite restaurants.
Right down below you’ll learn who in Marco Island is serving up the freshest fish, crabs, lobster, oysters, and so much more!
1215 Bald Eagle Dr, Marco Island, FL 34145
First up is Snook Inn located off of Bald Eagle Drive and this place has some unbelievably fresh seafood that you do not want to miss out on.
As you might expect, a place this close to the water is going to be getting the absolute freshest fish and shellfish delivered daily.
I always start with one of their cocktails, but it’s always hard to choose between them because they have so many. I really like the 1930s Mai Tai when I need something fruity and refreshing.
For food, it’s always a good idea to start with something from the raw bar, but then I’d recommend the seafood scampi for sure.
Leebe Fish Inc
350 Royal Palm Dr, Marco Island, FL 34145
Leebe Fish Inc is up next and you might recognize them from some of our other Marco Island lists.
“From Hook to Mouth” is the motto here at Leebe Fish Inc and they take that very seriously.
The seafood here comes straight off of the fishing boats and you can really taste the freshness.
They serve up some delicious fish sandwiches, platters, and even tacos, all featuring the catch-of-the-day fish. You never know what you’re going to get until you come in and check it out!
Whatever you do, be sure to save room for some of Lee’s Award-Winning Key Lime Pie, it’s unbeatable.
657 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL 34145
Up next, we have Fin Bistro. This charming little bistro is well-known and well-loved around the island, and for very good reason.
The seafood here is simply top-tier and the ambiance, as well as the service, is unparalleled.
Fin Bistro is located off of South Collier Boulevard, right across the street from the Hilton Marco Island Beach Resort and Spa and the Marriott’s Crystal Shores.
When you get to Fin Bistro, one of the best things to order is the almond crusted Key West hogfish. It comes with a russet potato puree, almondine butter sauce, and grilled asparagus.
CJ’s on the Bay
740 N Collier Blvd #105, Marco Island, FL 34145
This next place is called CJ’s on the Bay and you can find them off of North Collier Boulevard inside the Esplanade Shoppes at Marco Island, offering both waterfront views as well as shopping opportunities in one convenient spot.
One thing I love about this place is their stone crab entree. Stone crabs are a delicacy down here in Florida and if you see them on a restaurant’s menu, it’s definitely worth ordering.
They also have some truly delectable pasta options on the menu here at CJ’s. My favorite is the Key West pink shrimp pasta that comes topped with a fresh pine nut pesto sauce.
The Oyster Society
599 S Collier Blvd #218, Marco Island, FL 34145
Right inside of Marco Walk Plaza shopping center on the corner of South Collier Boulevard and Winterberry Drive is a place called The Oyster Society that you really don’t want to miss when you’re looking to try the top seafood restaurants Marco Island has to offer.
The Oyster Society is the number-one place I would recommend to anyone who loves oysters. The selection of fresh oysters here at The Oyster Society is unreal.
They serve oysters from all over the country and you can pick exactly where you want yours from. Definitely stop by The Oyster Society if you want to be blown away.
Mango’s Dockside Bistro
760 N Collier Blvd # 109, Marco Island, FL 34145
Mango’s Dockside Bistro is another great place to eat in the Esplanade Shoppes at Marco Island shopping mall.
I usually come here if I’m in the middle of a shopping spree and I need to stop and refuel with some fresh seafood before continuing.
What I love the most about this place, and what I recommend to you, is their weekend breakfast menu, but the lunch and dinner menus are also filled with delicious options as well.
I always get one of their mango mimosas and the savory seafood omelet. It’s really the optimal way to start any day.
900 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL 34145
The next place I want to recommend is Sunset Grille. You can check out this place off of South Collier Boulevard inside the Apollo Condominiums, conveniently located right next to the Marco Island South Public Beach Access.
It’s the perfect spot for seafood after a day at the beach or if you’re staying in the hotel.
This sports bar has incredible views of the Gulf of Mexico as well as plenty of TVs to watch the game on.
I usually come here when I’m in the mood for a frozen drink to beat the heat and some coconut shrimp to fill me up so I can get back to laying out in the sun.
Marco Prime Steak & Seafood Restaurant
599 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL 34145
Marco Prime Steak & Seafood Restaurant is a fixture of Marco Island and it’s where you need to go if you want an absolutely top-notch seafood dinner in a fine dining atmosphere.
Everything on the menu is expertly crafted with the highest quality ingredients to the point where you can taste the difference.
Of course, the surf n’ turf is always a great path to take, but some of my other favorite seafood entrees are the charred salmon and the blackened snapper.
The menu here at Marco Prime Steak & Seafood Restaurant is immense, so I also suggest grabbing a cocktail to sip on while you peruse it.
Little Bar Restaurant
205 Harbor Pl N, Goodland, FL 34140
Little Bar restaurant is the next place I want to mention and I really think this one will check all your boxes when it comes to what you want in a seafood restaurant.
Not only are the fish and shellfish as fresh as possible, but the waterfront views are really hard to beat.
Whenever I come to Little Bar, I find myself drawn towards the grouper sandwich or platter, depending on how I’m feeling.
That’s just one of the delectable dishes they serve here, though. They also serve frog legs if you’re feeling a bit adventurous. Amphibians count as seafood, right?
Da Vinci Ristorante Italiano
599 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL 34145
Next up is Da Vinci Ristorante Italiano and you can find this wonderful place in the same plaza as Marco Prime Steak and Seafood Restaurant, Marco Walk Plaza, right near the Winterberry Public Beach Access, so if you’re looking for a great place to get some classic Italian seafood dishes, then this is it.
When I come to Da Vinci Ristorante Italiano, I like to start with a glass of red wine while I check over the menu. It’s always a great idea to start with the fried calamari, but after that, I suggest the Chilean sea bass.
527 Bald Eagle Dr, Marco Island, FL 34145
Lastly, Kretch’s Restaurant is a hidden gem of Marco Island that I feel doesn’t get as much recognition as it probably deserves.
The seafood here is always so fresh and you can just tell that so much care was put into every dish.
I always start with the fresh steamed Prince Edward Island mussels as an appetizer, but then I go straight for a fried triple tail sandwich.
Triple tail is one of my favorite fish to eat, so if you ever see it on a menu, I highly recommend giving it a try.
Best Seafood in Marco Island
- Snook Inn
- Leebe Fish Inc
- Fin Bistro
- CJ’s on the Bay
- The Oyster Society
- Mango’s Dockside Bistro
- Sunset Grille
- Marco Prime Steak & Seafood Restaurant
- Little Bar Restaurant
- Da Vinci Ristorante Italiano
- Kretch’s Restaurant
When it comes to fish and shellfish, you’re going to be hard-pressed to find a city with a better assortment of seafood restaurants than Marco Island, Florida.
This little town is basically a fishing haven because even if you don’t catch anything all day, that doesn’t mean you can’t get fresh fish for dinner!
If you’re not looking for Marco Island seafood spots, you might want to check out some of these amazing brunch restaurants around town!
Did we leave a restaurant out of this list? Make sure you leave us a comment and we’ll check it out!
This page may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we'll earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.