Sea Isle City, a town right on the Jersey Shore, is a popular spot to visit the beach in New Jersey. This place is full of things to do and see with plenty of nightlife. Although, the restaurant scene can be easily overlooked.
When it comes to restaurants in this town, you won’t want to skip out on all of the delicious food here. I know it can be hard to know where to eat though, so I’ve compiled a list of my favorite eateries around town.
Looking for a quick place to grab a meal? You’ll find it on my list. A nice spot for a date night? Read below. How about a place with fresh seafood and a view of the water? It’s all in the list. Keep reading to learn more about each location!
Best Restaurants in Sea Isle City NJ
- Mike’s Seafood
- La Fontana Coast
- Bubba Dogs
- La Finestra Ristorante
- A Modo Mio Ristorante
- Marie’s Seafood
- Carmen’s Seafood Restaurant
- Andrea Trattoria Italiana II
- Basilicos Ristorante-Pizzeria
4222 Park Rd, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243
Phone: (609) 263-3458
With over 1,000 reviews on Google, it’s clear that Mike’s Seafood is a popular spot to grab some food. This local restaurant serves seafood cuisine right by the marina. With a BYOB policy, you’ll be able to save a bit of money too.
Mike’s Seafood’s menu is pretty extensive with platters, pasta, and more. We recommend the fresh jumbo gulf shrimp, lobster fra diavalo, the mighty macs, or grilled black angus N.Y. strip steak. Be sure to bring along your favorite drink!
La Fontana Coast
5000 Landis Ave, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243
Phone: (609) 486-6088
If Italian food is more your style, we suggest La Fontana Coast. Serving Italian cuisine in a Mediterranean style villa inspired interior, you’ll feel like you took a trip to Italy itself. With house-made pasta and a BYOB policy, you’ll never want to leave.
The menu at La Fontana Coast has all of your favorite Italian dishes plus more. Be sure to try the gnocchi alla gorgonzola, shrimp diavolo, pollo alla fontana, or vitello alla griglia. Don’t forget to take a bottle or two of your favorite wine with you!
5999-5901 Pleasure Ave, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243
Phone: (123) 456-7890
Looking for a fast and easy meal? Swing by Bubba Dogs. Opened in 2002, this local hotdog shop serves some of the best dogs in town. And with a 4.9 star rating, it’s clear that people absolutely love the food here.
Though the menu is a bit short at Bubba Dogs, it’s just as tasty as any other spot. Try out the 59th street, the Philly dilly, Bubba’s walking taco, or the double doink. Make sure to wash it down with a strawberry lemonade or limeade!
La Finestra Ristorante
25 John F Kennedy Blvd, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243
Phone: (609) 486-5033
Boasting a 4.8 star review, La Finestra Ristorante has been serving delicious food to the community for years. This local restaurant serves Italian cuisine made with local and quality ingredients. Prioritizing handmade dishes and an evolving menu, you’ll never get bored at this spot.
La Finestra Ristorante’s menu offers classic Italian dishes to choose from, so you really can’t go wrong here. We recommend the rigatoni alla vodka, langostinos alla griglia, la scarpariello, or al gorgonzola. Be sure to bring some wine as this spot is BYOB only!
A Modo Mio Ristorante
5900 Landis Ave, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243
Phone: (609) 486-5455
Sister restaurant to the last spot on our list is A Modo Mio Ristorante. Housed in a modern trattoria, this place serves up delicious Italian cuisine. And if you’re not a huge fan of BYOB spots, this is the restaurant for you as they offer plenty of wine.
There’s so many amazing dishes to try at A Modo Mio Ristorante. Be sure to try the saltimbocca alla romana, brasato al barolo, caprese, or capellini al granchio. Don’t forget to sip on a glass of wine with your meal!
4304 Park Rd, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243
Phone: (609) 263-3474
Doubling as a market and a restaurant, Marie’s Seafood should be at the top of your list when it comes to places to eat. This local restaurant sells and serves local seafood right by the marina. With seating on the outdoor deck, this is the perfect spot to soak up some sun.
Marie’s Seafood offers seafood platters for takeout as well as a lunch menu for dining on the deck. Try out the shrimp caesar salad, lobster roll sandwich, the dragger, the shrimp boat, or the hen house if you’re not a fan of fish!
Carmen’s Seafood Restaurant
353 43rd Pl, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243
Phone: (609) 263-3471
Established all the way back in 1943, Carmen’s Seafood Restaurant has decades of successful food service under its belt. This dockside restaurant serves up seafood cuisine, as you may have guessed in a boat-themed interior.
Serving lunch, dinner, and breakfast on the weekends, Carmen’s Seafood Restaurant is a great place to stop by whenever. We recommend Carmen’s house specialty, lobster scampi, grilled parmesan peppercorn chicken, or baked manicotti. Be sure to ask about their dessert selection!
Anthony’s Sea Isle City
4400 Landis Ave, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243
Phone: (609) 263-1200
A fairly new addition to the town’s restaurant scene is Anthony’s Sea Isle City. This local restaurant opened in just 2020 and serves authentic Italian cuisine. It also has a BYOB policy, so you may be able to save a bit of money.
The menu at Anthony’s Sea Isle City is the perfect combination of Italian cuisine and fresh seafood. Be sure to try the gnocchi with homemade meatballs, veal chop, chicken stephen, or blackened Atlantic salmon and scallops. Don’t forget to bring along a bottle!
Andrea Trattoria Italiana II
4216 Park Rd, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243
Phone: (609) 263-5001
Established back in 2005, Andrea Trattoria Italiana II has become a community favorite in the last decade and a half. As the name may suggest, this spot serves classic Italian cuisine. This family-owned and run restaurant is all about traditions and family.
With so many great options to choose from at Andrea Trattoria Italiana II, you may have a hard time picking something. Try out the tagliolini neri con gamberi, fettucini al granchio alfredo, vitello con carciofi, or pollo algi asparagi!
27 43rd St, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243
Phone: (609) 263-1010
Completing our list of restaurants is Basilicos Ristorante-Pizzeria. Yet another Italian restaurant, this spot serves homemade dishes like pasta. Housed in a casual space, this place is perfect for any occasion, big or small.
Offering a dinner menu as well as a pizza menu, there’s so many amazing things to taste at Basilicos Ristorante-Pizzeria. We recommend the pescatore passomonti, agnello desiderio, ravioli ann marie, or bbq stuffed pie. Be sure to snag a cannoli, cheesecake, or tiramisu on your way out!
As you can see, there’s an endless supply of food to try in this Jersey Shore town. No matter what your taste is like, you’ll have plenty of places to eat here. So if you’re ever in a bind, you’ll know exactly where to go.
Which spot are you most excited about? Let us know! Did we leave a restaurant out of this list? Make sure you tell us about it and we’ll check it out!
This page may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we'll earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.