Located right off the coast of New Jersey, Sandy Hook is a well-known spot in the state. Much like other parts of New Jersey and towns along the Jersey Shore, this one is full of tasty restaurants you have to try when you visit. I know when traveling or even when living somewhere, it can be hard to find restaurants that have good food, service, and meet all of your needs. So, I’ve put together a list of my favorite places to eat in town so you’ll know exactly what to expect at each spot.
Whether you want some classic seafood, Italian cuisine, or some laid-back pub food, there’s a spot for all of it on my list. I’ve also included multiple spots with waterfront views so you can really take in your surroundings. Keep reading to learn a bit about each place!
Best Restaurants in Sandy Hook
- Ohana Isle
- Inlet Cafe
- Bahrs Landing Famous Seafood Restaurant & Marina
- Proving Ground Waterfront Dining
- Off The Hook Restaurant and Bar
- Gianna’s Italian Restaurant
- Moby’s Lobsters Deck
- The Chubby Pickle
- Fresh Bistro
North Beach, Atlantic Dr, Sandy Hook, NJ 07732
Phone: (732) 333-8985
Hoping to have a taste of Hawaii without leaving NJ? Check out Ohana Isle. This local restaurant serves up authentic Hawaiian cuisine you won’t want to miss. Located right on North Beach you can even put your feet in the sand to really get that tropical feel.
Ohana Isle serves a set list of entrees and desserts along with a weekly rotating special. We recommend the Spam musubi, aloha pulled pork, big wave fish tacos, or aloha dog. Be sure to grab a Dole pineapple float before your leave!
3 Cornwall St, Highlands, NJ 07732
Phone: (732) 872-9764
Opened in 1966, Inlet Cafe is the perfect spot to enjoy some great food and beautiful views. This family-owned restaurant serves up fresh seafood overlooking Sandy Hook Bay. With hundreds of reviews about the food and service, it’s clear this spot has done well.
Serving a full menu including non-seafood options and a raw bar, Inlet Cafe has something for everyone. Be sure to try the New Orleans jambalaya, New England lobster roll, baja tacos, or seafood linguine. Don’t forget to sip on a frozen cocktail while you eat!
Bahrs Landing Famous Seafood Restaurant & Marina
2 Bay Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732
Phone: (732) 872-1245
With over 2,000 reviews, it’s clear that Bahrs Landing Famous Seafood Restaurant & Marina is a popular restaurant. Open since 1917, you can count on this spot having the whole food service thing down. Serving seafood overlooking the water, it can’t get much better than this.
Bahrs Landing offers a menu full of amazing seafood dishes to indulge in. Try out the Caribbean shrimp curry, bourbon glazed salmon, seafood sampler, or crispy soft shell crabs. Make sure to try a specialty cocktail while you eat!
Proving Ground Waterfront Dining
56 Shrewsbury Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732
Phone: (732) 872-2266
Looking for a spot with options for the whole family? Head over to Proving Ground Waterfront Dining. This local restaurant serves American cuisine with a wide range of dishes to choose from. With fire pits and views of the bay, you’re sure to enjoy a meal here.
Proving Ground adjusts their menu fairly frequently, so there’s always plenty to try here. We recommend the cajun mahi sandwich, pasta bolognese, steak sandwich, or baked three cheese mac. Be sure to stop by from 10 a.m. to 1 p.m. on Sunday for brunch!
Off The Hook Restaurant and Bar
1 NJ-36, Highlands, NJ 07732
Phone: (732) 872-2006
Keeping with the theme of waterfront dining, Off The Hook Restaurant and Bar is a spot you have to try while in town. Serving American cuisine in hearty portions next to the full bar, you’ll find everything you need here.
The menu at Off The Hook has a balanced mix of seafood dishes and classic American plates. Be sure to try the sun burnt pasta, baby back ribs, mahi mahi tacos, or hooked up burger. Don’t forget to grab a drink or two from the bar!
Gianna’s Italian Restaurant
122 Bay Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732
Phone: (732) 769-6377
In the mood for some Italian food? We suggest Gianna’s Italian Restaurant. This family-owned and operated restaurant serves delicious Italian cuisine. People love the food, service, and family-friendly atmosphere at this spot.
Offering all of your favorite Italian dishes including family-style takeout, Gianna’s Italian Restaurant is great for any occasion. Try out the gnocchi basilico, pappardelle giovanni, chicken parmesan vodka style, or sole oreganato. Make sure to finish your meal with some cheesecake or a cannolI!
Moby’s Lobster Deck
2 Bay Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732
Phone: (732) 872-1245
Established in 1970, Moby’s Lobster Deck has been serving delicious food for decades now. This neighborhood spot serves seafood, as you may have guessed, with waterfront seating. With a raw bar and beer, you’ll be able to kill a few hours here.
Moby’s Lobster Deck has both seafood-centered and non-seafood dishes, so you can bring along your friends who don’t like fish too. We recommend the lobster roll, crab cake, clam bake, or chicken sandwich. Be sure to grab some beer, wine, or sangria!
The Chubby Pickle
23 Bay Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732
Phone: (732) 872-7000
Searching for a laid-back spot to enjoy some food and drinks? We suggest The Chubby Pickle. This local sports bar serves up traditional pub fare with an emphasis on comfort food. With TVs, live music, and open mic nights, there’s plenty to keep you entertained here.
With all of your favorite bar snacks and entrees, you’ll find whatever it is you’re in the mood for at The Chubby Pickle. Be sure to try the BBQ bacon jalapeno burger, smoked chicken tacos, Caribbean island steak, or shrimp mac and cheese. Don’t forget to have a couple of drinks!
168 Bay Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732
Phone: (732) 291-3080
With a 4.8 star rating on Google, it’s no wonder Porcini draws in so many patrons. This neighborhood restaurant offers classic Italian cuisine and wine. With a traditional dining room, this is the perfect nice spot to enjoy a meal.
Porcini’s menu is straightforward with numerous great choices. Try out the five cheese ravioli, garganelli, duck duo, or grilled hanger steak. Make sure to order some peanut butter banana cream pie or cheesecake du jour for dessert!
144 Bay Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732
Phone: (732) 708-0328
Completing our list of restaurants is Fresh Bistro. Another local restaurant serving Italian cuisine, you can bet the food here is delicious. With numerous five-star reviews, there’s no doubt your experience here will be top-notch.
Fresh Bistro’s menu is pretty modest, but just as tasty as other spots. We recommend the fresh tagliatelle, chicken milanese, barolo braised beef short rib, or satueed fresh Maine lobster. Be sure to try the chocolate creme brulee or tiramisu for dessert!
So, whenever you can’t decide where to grab some dinner, you’ll be able to come back to this list to solve your problem. If one thing is clear from my list, it’s that this Jersey Shore town offers countless dining experiences.
Which spot are you most excited to try? Let us know! Did we leave a restaurant out of this list? Make sure you leave us a comment and we’ll check it out!
This page may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we'll earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.