Right on the tip of New Jersey’s peninsula, Cape May is a great city filled with shops, restaurants, and Victorian era houses. Whether you’re visiting for a few days or live in the town, you’re bound to get hungry at some point. When it comes to trying new food, I know it can be a little difficult to find the perfect spot. That’s why I’ve put together a list of my favorite places to eat so you can know what to expect at each restaurant.
With plenty of fresh seafood and other delicious cuisines, you’ll want to try every place on my list. From high-end, refined locations to a little more casual ones, there’s a restaurant for every occasion here. Keep reading to learn a bit about each location!
Best Restaurants in Cape May
- Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant
- Tisha’s Fine Dining
- Washington Inn
- Lucky Bones Back Water Grille
- Ebbitt Room
- 410 Bank Street Restaurant
- Aleathea’s Restaurant
- The Lobster House
- The Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar
- Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar
Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant
1301 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204
Phone: (609) 884-9090
Doubling as a hotel and a restaurant, Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant is one of the top places to grab food in town. This spot serves high-end, modern American cuisine you won’t want to miss out on.
Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant offers a three course meal, with plenty of options for each course. We recommend the yellowfin tuna tartare, orecchiette, or PSI surf and turf. Be sure to check out the desert menu with options like spiced creme brulee and toffee pudding!
Tisha’s Fine Dining
322 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204
Phone: (609) 884-9119
Looking for a classy place for a special occasion? Check out Tisha’s Fine Dining. Serving New American cuisine in a refined interior. This restaurant is BYOB, so be sure to come prepared if you’re hoping to drink.
Serving delicious dishes for lunch and dinner, this is a great spot for either meal. Be sure to try the Thai salmon and shrimp, pork tenderloin, 2020 burger, or veal Milanese sandwich. Don’t forget to bring along a bottle fo your favorite wine!
801 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204
Phone: (609) 884-5697
Another hotel restaurant duo you have to try is Washington Inn. This spot alsos erves high-end New American cuisine. People love the delicious food, perfect drinks, and friendly and helpful service at this spot.
Washington Inn’s menu is pretty modest, but full of decadent dishes. Try out the rack of New Zealand lamb, Washington Inn crab cakes, the vegan, or grilled Meyers Ranch flatiron steak. Make sure to sip on a glass of wine with your meal!
Lucky Bones Back Water Grille
1200 NJ-109, Cape May, NJ 08204
Phone: (609) 884-2663
If you like seafood, you’re going to love Lucky Bones Back Water Grille. This local restaurant serves American cuisine with an emphasis on seafood. With a family-friendly atmosphere, this is the perfect place for take out night with the kids.
Lucky Bones Back Water Grille offers plenty of delicious plates and comfort food. We recommend the crab and shrimp cakes, famous Lucky Bones mussels and pasta, sofia pie, or rollin’ bones smash burger. They also have gluten-free options!
25 Jackson St, Cape May, NJ 08204
Phone: (609) 884-5700
In search of the freshest food around? We suggest Ebbitt Room. This local restaurant serves New American food made from seasonal and sustainable ingredients. With a farm-to-table approach, you’re bound to have some amazing food.
Ebbitt Room offers a raw bar, appetizers, and main courses, all of which are delicious. Be sure to try the miso glazed Atlantic halibut, aged peking duck breast, avocado ceviche, or tagliatelle pasta. Don’t forget to sip on a specialty cocktail or martini!
410 Bank Street Restaurant
410 Bank St, Cape May, NJ 08204
Phone: (609) 884-2127
When you want to try something a little different, head over to 410 Bank Street Restaurant. This unique restaurant serves French New Orleans cuisine with a Caribbean twist. Housed in a Victorian house draped with tropical plants, you’ll feel relaxed the second you step into this spot.
There’s so many tasty plates to try at 410 Bank Street Restaurant including a few gluten-free and dairy-free choices. Try out the cajun shellfish gumbo file, voodoo shrimp, Jamaican steak, or herb crusted rack of lamb!
7 Ocean St, Cape May, NJ 08204
Phone: (609) 884-5555 ext. 226
Housed in similar setting to the last spot on our list, Aleathea’s Restaurant is a fantastic place to grab food in Cape May. Serving American cuisine in a Victorian inn, you’ll feel sophisticated and classy in this spot. With a waterfront and an elegant interior, it’s perfect for a celebration.
Aleathea’s Restaurant serves an amazing menu with plenty to enjoy. We recommend the shrimp scampi, seafood linguini, tacos, or cheesesteak. Be sure to grab a drink from the bar to go with your meal!
The Lobster House
906 Schellengers Landing Rd, Cape May, NJ 08204
Phone: (609) 884-8296
Another seafood-centered restaurant you have to try in town is The Lobster House. With nearly 7,000 reviews on Google, it’s obvious this spot is incredibly popular. With dockside seating, you’ll be able to take in the atmosphere at this restaurant.
Though they primarily serve seafood dishes, The Lobster House has a few other selections if fish isn’t really your thing. Be sure to try the baked stuffed shrimp, crabmeat au gratin, chicken francaise, or filet mignon!
The Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar
19 Jackson St, Cape May, NJ 08204
Phone: (609) 884-5970
Located in the Carroll Villa Hotel, The Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar is a spectacular spot you can’t miss when it comes to food and drinks. This restaurant serves American cuisine in a welcoming atmosphere with live music.
The Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, so it’s great for any time of the day. Try out the Chesapeake Bay benedict, vegetable panini, chorizo sausage paella, or grilled vegetable ravioli. They also have plenty of vegan options!
Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar
615 Lafayette St, Cape May, NJ 08204
Phone: (609) 884-2111
Finishing up our list of restaurants is Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar. This local restaurant serves steak and seafood in a nautical-themed interior. Upscale yet still casual enough for day-to-day dining, this is the perfect place for any occasion.
Offering classic dishes and a few unique ones, everyone will find something to love here. We recommend the seafood pot pie, New England clambake, crispy duck breast, or veal san marco. Be sure to finish up with a delicious cocktail!
So, the next time you can’t decide where to eat, you can come back to my list to find the perfect spot for your occasion. If there’s one thing this list proves, it’s that this Jersey Shore town has some of the best restaurants.
Which spot are you most excited to try? Let us know! Did we leave a restaurant out of this list? Make sure you mention it below and we’ll check it out!
This page may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we'll earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.