Tribeca is home to the world-famous Little Italy neighborhood, with a rich cultural history and some of the best Italian food outside of Italy. Old-world Italian culture mixes seamlessly with American values and traditions to create a whole new identity from which hails the almighty New York-style pizza.
Its giant round size, thin, crunchy, and chewy crust, and cheap by-the-slice serving style made pizza the quintessential New York staple. Other large cities like Detroit and Chicago took a lesson from New York, creating their own adaptations on this beloved Italian American snack.
When looking for where to get pizza in Tribeca, you may feel overwhelmed because you’ll find pizza on every corner like any other neighborhood in New York. However, not all pizza is created equal.
My quest for the perfect slice bore the tastiest success. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Tribeca, you’ll find it on my thoroughly researched and taste-tested list of the top 7 pizza restaurants.
- Il Mattone
- Little Italy Pizza
- Gigino Trattoria
- Tribeca Pizza
- Friendly Gourmet Pizza
- Joe’s Pizza
325 Church St, New York, NY 10013
Located down the block from the famous Canal Street and a short walk from Bloomingdales, Saluggi’s is an authentic Neapolitan pizzeria and sports bar with a warm, family-friendly atmosphere and a second location on Grand. Saluggi’s has a traditional brick oven, serving wood-fired brick oven pizzas along with wings, pasta, hero sandwiches, and typical Italian antipasti.
Saluggi’s food is affordable with a wide variety of delicious options to enjoy in its small brick-walled, checker table-clothed interior replete with old-fashioned New York streetlights. It’s hard to pass up their classic sausage and peppers hero with Italian sausage, roasted peppers, caramelized onions, marinara, and parmesan. That said, their pizza is the star of the show. Try Italian Deli specialty pie with salami, capicola, caramelized onions, red sauce, provolone, fresh mozzarella, and parmesan.
49 Beach St, New York, NY 10013
Located right off the Hudson and two blocks from the CUNY Manhattan campus, Il Mattone has been a neighborhood favorite for years, attracting New Yorkers from every borough to sample their classic New York-style pies. Whether you want to pick up a quick slice, order delivery, or dine inside their cozy, warm space, Il Mattone accommodates all dining and dietary preferences.
Not only do they sell pizza by the slice and whole round New York-style pies, but they also make a fantastic square-shaped Sicilian pizza with a denser, thicker crust. Their menu also features sandwiches, calzones, salads, soup, pasta, and appetizers. I recommend spinach, arugula, and artichoke pie for vegetarians. If you’re on the go, grab a slice of pepperoni and jalapeno.
154 Church St, New York, NY 10007
Located a few blocks from City Hall Park, Little Italy Pizza is a classic New York-style pizzeria with various locations around the city. To accommodate the city that never sleeps, Little Italy is open 24-hours so that you can grab a fresh slice at 2 a.m. on your walk home from bar hopping.
The Church Street location has a sizable dine-in area, and just a few blocks south, there’s a take-out, delivery, and by the slice window for even faster service. Their garlic knots are delicious, made fresh daily, and always piping hot. I found their red Sicilian slice with mozzarella, parmesan, oregano, red sauce, and olive oil to be the perfect slice.
323 Greenwich St, New York, NY 10013
Located right in front of Washington Market Park, Gigino Trattoria is a Tribeca favorite for the finest, most authentic Italian food in an elegant yet homey environment.
Restaurateurs Bob Giraldi and Phil Suarez, along with head Chef Luigi Celantano, founded Gigino Trattoria in 1994, serving traditional Italian pasta, entrees, and pizza using the freshest ingredients and making all pasta, bread, and pizza dough in house.
Their pasta is made to order, the chef literally rolling out the dough and cutting it after receiving your order, so I would most definitely try a pasta dish. I loved the ravioli al pesto with cheese stuffed ravioli in basil pesto with fresh tomato and pecorino cheese. Their pizza is to die for and some of the fanciest on my list. I recommend the Tartufata pizza with grilled chicken, radicchio, endive, mushrooms, asiago cheese, and truffle.
270 Greenwich St, New York, NY 10007
Believe it or not, some of the best Tribeca pizza is located inside Whole Foods Market. Tribeca Pizza is an eatery inside Whole Foods, serving exquisite Neapolitan and New York-style pies made with the very best organic ingredients delivered fresh daily. Vegetarian and vegan options abound, and the ample, airy dining space is a great place to enjoy a slice or a pie on your lunch break.
If you’re doing a big shop and don’t have the energy to make a meal after unloading your groceries, you can always order a large pie for take-out on your way out. Their Neapolitan pie with pecorino, arugula, and prosciutto is authentic and fresh.
59 Nassau St, New York, NY 10038
Located a short walk from the New York Stock Exchange, Friendly Gourmet Pizza is a New York-style pizza stand inside a cute triangular-shaped space on a busy New York street corner. They epitomize the typical New York pizza joint you see in the movies- or on every street corner if you live in NYC. Their pizza is the very best New York pizza archetype.
Friendly Gourmet is a delivery or takeout joint with options for by the slice, New York-style, Chicago-style, and Sicilian. They make delicious Cesar salads, too! Despite the infamously high food and rent prices, you can still get a massive slice of classic cheese pizza for under $3 at Friendly Gourmet.
124 Fulton St, New York, NY 10038
Named for the owner, founder, and Naples-native Joe Pozzuoli, Joe’s Pizza has been the pride and joy of New York since it opened in Greenwich Village in 1975. You can still see Joe rolling out the dough and hoisting pies out of the oven at 75 years old. Joe’s Pizza has received numerous accolades, with New York Magazine calling its no-frills and utterly delicious pies “the quintessential New York slice.”
In Tribeca, Joe’s Pizza lies a few blocks from City Hall Park and offers a simple menu of New York and Sicilian-style pies that truly are the best in New York. You can get a simple mozzarella pie or build your own with a small selection of toppings.
Tribeca pizza has everything from fine-dining specialty pies to casual late-night slices. Whether you want a sit-down pizza dinner or a quick slice, you’ll get the most delicious pizza in Tribeca from one of the excellent pizza restaurants on my list.
You enjoy the best pizza in Tribeca for dinner, but you’ll need to find some breakfast and lunch options to complete your culinary experience, so check out my list of the best brunch restaurants in Tribeca.
This page may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we'll earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.