in ,

Where to Get the Perfect Slice of Pizza in Park Slope

Grab a slice or a whole pie at these spots in the area

Locals and visitors alike agree that Park Slope is one of the most beautiful places in Brooklyn. From tree-lined streets to the green grasses of Prospect Park, it’s a great place to spend your day. Stop by the Park Slope Co-op or spend a Saturday at the Grand Army Plaza Greenmarket. It’s a great place to do some boutique shopping or relax at a local coffee shop.

perfect slice of pizza in park slope

NYC is the birthplace of pizza! Everyone knows you can find a great slice in the 5 boroughs. New Yorkers are particular about their pies. Park Slope itself offers pizza in every style, for all tastes. Find everything, from strictly traditional to trendy. You’ll find something here that meets your pizza requirements! Grab a pizza and head out into this iconic Brooklyn neighborhood.

From Grand Army Plaza to the Park Slope Armory YMCA, I’ve been to all kinds of pizza places in Brooklyn. I’ll share with you what I think are the top-notch places you must visit. Check out my list of the best pizza in Park Slope, Brooklyn, below!

Best Pizza in Park Slope

  1. Peppino’s
  2. Pizza Town
  3. Patsy’s Pizzeria
  4. Roma Pizza
  5. Two Boots Park Slope
  6. Pizza Plus
  7. Artichoke Basille’s Pizza
  8. Numero 28 Pizzeria
  9. American Cheez
  10. L’Arte Della Pizza Brooklyn
  11. Baciccia Pizza e Cucina

Peppino’s

469 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Phone: 1718-768-0176
Visit Website

First, on my list of the best pizza in Park Slope, Brooklyn, check out Peppino’s. Originally established in 2004 in Bay Ridge, Peppino’s quickly became a Brooklyn favorite and expanded in 2008. 

Their second Brooklyn location is on 5th Avenue between 10th and 11th Street. A family-owned business, they also have a liquor and wine shop and offer a selection at their pizza restaurants.

Any day of the week, you’ll find Peppino’s busy, which any New Yorker will tell you is the sign of a good restaurant. Step inside, and you’ll find classic checkered tablecloths topped with shakers of parmesan and chili flakes. All of Peppino’s pizza is prepared in their wood-burning oven. Try their antipasto appetizer that’s always fresh and order my favorite, their famous “Pizza I Dunno.”


Pizza Town

85 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Phone: 718-789-4040

After shopping at Beacon’s Closet, step into Pizza Town on 5th Avenue between Prospect Place and Park Place. Proprietor Vinny originally opened his establishment as V & M Pizza in 1987. Today you’ll find someone tossing dough behind the counter of this very classic Brooklyn pizza parlor.

Order a slice or a whole pie. They also offer other Italian classics, such as calzones, pasta, garlic knots, and sandwiches. Pizza Town makes my list of best pizza places in Park Slope, Brooklyn, for their sauce that’s on the sweeter, garlicky side. For a great meal at this stop, I recommend the white slice or chicken buffalo slice.


Patsy’s Pizzeria

450 Dean St, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Phone: 718-622-2268
Visit Website

Located across from the Barclays Center on the corner of Dean Street and Flatbush Avenue, find Patsy’s Pizzeria. Pasquale “Patsy” Lancieri immigrated from Italy and in 1933 opened the original Patsy’s in East Harlem. Today, this iconic pizza restaurant is beloved, having locations all over NYC.

The Dean Street location is beautiful, with ample indoor and outdoor seating. The culinary experience is elevated from the typical pizza parlor but with classic pies (no slices). You can get beautifully presented salads, pasta dishes, and desserts, as well as cocktails. When it comes to pizza, order a classic cheese pizza. The dough is soft and flavourful just out of their brick ovens.


Roma Pizza

85 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Phone: 718-783-7334
Visit Website

Find Roma Pizza on 7th Avenue between Berkeley Place and Union Street. A neighborhood mainstay, people who have moved out of NYC, come back here just for a pie. Roma Pizza has been open for over 40 years. Visit during the holidays to check out fun artwork painted on the walls and mirrors!

On my list of the best pizza in Park Slope, Brooklyn, this is the place to try a fresh mozzarella slice or a garlic knot crust pie. If you’re really hungry, also try the cheese sticks and garlic knots. Keep in mind that they accept only cash payments.


Two Boots Park Slope

284 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Phone: 718-499-0008
Visit Website

Next on my list of the best pizza in Park Slope, Brooklyn, is the very unique Two Boots Park Slope. Find them on the corner of 5th Avenue and 1st Street. They’re always busy, and you’ll probably see several strollers parked out front.

This family-friendly pizza parlor is one of a handful of locations that started in the East Village in the 70s. Dreamed up by filmmakers with a love for both Italy and New Orleans, Two Boots is the result. Order fun twists on classic pizza flavors and Italian dishes.

Pizza purists may not frequent Two Boots, but they certainly have their place in Brooklyn. From the awning to the interior design and music, you can see the Cajun influence. Pizzas are created in honor of actors, musicians, and NYC characters. Try my favorite pizza here. The popular “V is for Vegan” pizza!


Pizza Plus 

359 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Phone: 718-768-5327
Visit Website

 Make sure to visit Pizza Plus on 7th Avenue between 10th and 11th Street. This family-owned restaurant has been serving up some of the best pizza in Park Slope, Brooklyn, for over 30 years. Stop by Pizza Plus if you are looking for a quality slice at a decent price or if you have dietary restrictions. They are popular for their vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free pizzas.

Sit inside or enjoy spacious seating on their covered patio out back. The broccoli rabe and chicken hero is popular with regulars, as is their calamari. For pizza, I recommend a classic Grandma pie. On it, you’ll find Russo’s mozzarella. Russo’s is 2 doors down from Pizza Plus and has been making fresh mozzarella for decades.


Artichoke Basille’s Pizza

59 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Phone: 347-763-1975
Visit Website

Next on my list of the best pizza in Park Slope, Brooklyn, is the wildly popular Artichoke Basille’s Pizza. Visit the Park Slope location on 5th Avenue between Bergen Street and St. Marks Place near the Barclays Center. The first Artichoke Basille’s was started by Staten Island natives in the East Village in 2008.

Today, founders and cousins Francis Garcia and Sal Basille have 7 NYC locations and more across the US. They have been on TV and are popular with both celebrities and local New Yorkers alike. There’s just something next-level about their decadent and flavorful pizza. Get the artichoke pizza or a vodka pie, and you won’t be sorry!


Numero 28 Pizzeria

137 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Phone: 718-398-9198
Visit Website

This small chain restaurant has 5 locations in NYC and a presence in New Jersey, Florida, and Texas. Find Numero 28 Park Slope on 7th Avenue between Carroll Street and Garfield Place, across from Key Foods. 

Numero 28 earns a place on my list of the best pizza in Park Slope, Brooklyn, for their attention to excellence. They are DOC certified, using only specific ingredients and techniques that meet Neapolitan pizza-making standards.

Try their thin-crust pizza, made in wood-burning brick stoves. Order a round pie, a sheet, or a square slice cut from a sheet. Try a classic Margherita slice or if you’re brave, get a truffle cheese pizza!


American Cheez

444 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Phone: 347-725-4665

For a true taste of Brooklyn, stop by American Cheez on 7th Avenue and 15th Street. This local watering hole runs on pizza, beer, and nostalgia. Come for the atmosphere and stay for the simplest of pleasures as a pint and a slice.

Walk in and you’ll either love it or hate it at American Cheez. Find sports games on the tv and 80s memorabilia covering every inch of wall space from behind the bar to the bathroom. Prices are kept low with no cash minimum, and the pizza is simple but delicious. I recommend ordering a classic pale lager and their pepperoni pizza with marinated jalapeños.


L’Arte Della Pizza Brooklyn

172 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Phone: 718-622-7200
Visit Website

Check out L’Arte Della on 5th Avenue between Degraw and Sackett Street. Look for the cherry red storefront. Pizzaiolo Riccardo Villani immigrated from Italy and started L’Arte with his family. Made in wood-burning brick ovens, you know you’re getting an authentic slice from an Italian!

Making the list of the best pizza in Park Slope, Brooklyn, the mushroom slice really shines here. They also have a delicious pesto and smoked mozzarella pizza, and the pasta dishes are to die for. Sit inside on a high stool if it’s quiet, or enjoy the outdoor seating with a view of 5th Avenue.


Baciccia Pizza e Cucina

426A 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Phone: 718-788-1000
Visit Website

Stop by Baciccia for a slice and enjoy a beautiful, relaxing dining experience. On 7th Avenue between 14th and 15th Street, this pizzeria rounds out my list of the best pizza in Park Slope, Brooklyn. They specialize in Roman-style pizza and fresh Italian cuisine.

Baciccia has a beautiful open backyard and seating out front. Sit indoors at tables or the bar for the atmosphere. Order the bufala pizza and enjoy wine from southern Italy. They also have 4 different kinds of white pizza on the menu that show the elevated quality of this pizza dining experience.


Final Thoughts

You have your choice when it comes to the best pizza in Park Slope, Brooklyn. Go with the old-school pizza purists or join the hipster and yuppies with the trendiest of pizza flavors. Eat your slice in the local watering hole or the family-run pizzeria where neighbors stop by just to say hi. 

If you’re not in the mood for pizza in Park Slope, you might like some of these awesome places to get brunch nearby in Bushwick!

We hope you found a new place to try pizza in Brooklyn. Did we leave a restaurant out of this list? Make sure you leave us a comment, and we’ll check it out!

This page may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we'll earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Written by Kyle Green

Kyle lives in Center City, Philadelphia, and never passes up the opportunity to try a new restaurant. As a former New Yorker of 7 years, he enjoys regular trips up to NYC to visit friends and enjoys all the restaurants and activities both cities have to offer.