in ,

Where to Get the Perfect Slice of Pizza in Panama City

Grab a slice or a whole pie at these awesome pizza places.

Most people, when they think of Panama City, think of beautiful white sugar sand beaches and crystal clear waters, which is pretty accurate for the most part. One thing you might not expect to find here, however, is delicious pizza.

friends eating at a pizza spot in panama city

If you happen to find yourself in Panama City craving a slice of pizza or maybe even a whole pie, then you might be wondering where to go for the best experience. If that’s the case, then I’ve definitely got something that will help you out. You see, I went on a mission to search the city far and wide to locate all the best places to get pizza, and I came back with quite the list.

Right down below, you’ll find my guide ranking the most popular pizza spots in Panama City. These eleven pizzerias are my absolute favorite pizza places in the whole city and I think they’re going to become yours too, so go ahead and get started and try some of the best pizza Panama City has to offer.

Best Pizza Restaurants in Panama City

  1. Shore Shack Pizza
  2. Bricks & Barley Pizza
  3. Trigo Deli
  4. Paparazzi Gourmet Deli
  5. St. Andrews Slice House
  6. Enzo’s Pizza and Grill
  7. Reds Pizza
  8. Pana Roma Pizza & Pasta
  9. New York’s Famous Pizza & Pasta
  10. Pizza Amore
  11. Ramon’s Pizza

Shore Shack Pizza

4900 Thomas Dr, Panama City Beach, FL 32408
Phone: 850-708-3187
Visit Website

First up on my list of best pizza places in Panama City is Shore Shack Pizza. You can find this place over off of Thomas Drive near the Treasure Island Resort Condominiums and St. Andrew’s State Park.

What I love about the pizza from Shore Shack is that it always tastes so fresh and the crust is just perfect every time. Not to mention, they have a wide assortment of craft beers on tap that will complement your pizza in the best way possible.

I highly recommend a classic pepperoni pizza from Shore Shack, but there are plenty of other amazing options like their Buffalo chicken pizza.

Bricks & Barley Pizza

8721 Thomas Dr Suite A, Panama City Beach, FL 32408
Phone: 850-775-1677
Visit Website

This next place is called Bricks & Barley Pizza and it’s another favorite of mine off Thomas Drive. You can find them right across the street from the Emerald Falls Family Rec Center, so it’s absolutely ideal for any families looking for pizza after a day of fun activities.

The pizza menu here at Bricks & Barley is divided into 4 categories: traditional pizzas, meat pizzas, chicken pizzas, and veggie pizzas, so it’s easy to find exactly what you want.

My favorite pizza to order from Bricks & Barley is Newby-Q pizza that comes with delicious BBQ chicken on top, as well as ricotta, mozzarella, red onions, and cilantro.

Trigo San Francisco Style Deli & Catering

119 Harrison Ave, Panama City, FL 32401
Phone: 850-481-0132
Visit Website

Trigo San Francisco Style Deli & Catering is the next restaurant that I would recommend for amazing pizza. The only caveat, however, is that they only serve pizza here on Wednesdays and Thursdays from 4 to 9 and on Fridays all day long, so plan accordingly!

My favorite pizza to order from Trigo is, hands-down, the Mexican chicken pizza. It’s so unique and different that I can never resist when I come in.

Look for Trigo on Harrison Avenue near the Panama City Center for the Arts and McKenzie Park. You definitely won’t be disappointed once you try it.

Paparazzi Gourmet Deli

2810 Thomas Dr, Panama City Beach, FL 32408
Phone: 850-588-8244
Visit Website

Now, we arrive at Paparazzi Gourmet Deli. I absolutely love to come to Paparazzi when I’m craving pizza, but they also offer tons of Italian dishes and even party platters if you need to cater an event.

My absolute favorite pizza that I always order from Paparazzi is their pink shrimp pizza. It comes topped with fresh shrimp, mozzarella, and their famous pink sauce that will simply blow your mind.

Be sure to check out Paparazzi Gourmet Deli off of Thomas Drive near the Hampton Inn Panama City Beach and Dat Cajun Place, another one of our favorite PCB destinations.

St. Andrews Slice House

1127 1/2 Beck Ave, Panama City, FL 32401
Phone: 850-541-9126
Visit Website

Next up is St. Andrews Slice House that’s located over off of ½ Beck Avenue in the historic part of town, right near the St. Andrews Marina and Oaks by the Bay Park.

What I love about St. Andrews Slice House is the sheer variety of specialty pies that they offer which you probably won’t find anywhere else. I strongly recommend trying one of their jerk pies that comes with mozzarella, jerk chicken, pineapple, peppadews, and topped with a delectable pesto drizzle.

Don’t worry, though, if you’re not into the crazy specialty pies, the classic pepperoni and cheese pizza is always delicious here as well.

Enzo’s Pizza and Grill

1322 Beck Ave, Panama City, FL 32401
Phone: 850-215-4562
Visit Website

Enzo’s Pizza and Grill is a charming little pizza parlor that everyone needs to visit during their time in Panama City. This pizza joint is laid-back and casual, serving some of the best pizza in Panama City.

You can find Enzo’s Pizza and Grill over on the corner of Beck Avenue and West 14th Street, just north of The Market at St. Andrews.

When you get here, be sure to try a signature double-decker pizza. The double-decker pizza from Enzo’s consists of 2 Chicago-style thin crust pizzas stacked together to form something truly special.

Reds Pizza

1305 E 5th St, Panama City, FL 32401
Visit Website

Reds Pizza is the next place I want to talk about and they’re located over on East 5th Street near the Old Orchard neighborhood. This place is about as low key as it gets, and there’s a real chance you might drive right past it without knowing, but you definitely want to stop in here, trust me.

Reds is Family-owned and operated and they’ve been a fixture of Panama City for a while now, for good reason. I always start with an order of their cheesy knots, but that’s just to get warmed up for the pizza.

Pana Roma Pizza & Pasta

840 W 23rd St, Panama City, FL 32405
Phone: 850-769-9466
Visit Website

Right inside the Stanford Station Shopping Center is another amazing pizza place in Panama City called Pana Roma Pizza & Pasta. Check them out on West 23rd Street near the Woodland Estates and Edgewood neighborhoods.

When you arrive at Pana Roma, I highly recommend trying a Tony’s Special supreme pizza. This pie will seriously rock your world, especially if you like classic New York-style pizza.

If you’re not feeling pizza from Pana Roma, then you should definitely consider a stromboli or calzone instead. Both of these options are simply delightful. Don’t forget a cold beer or nice glass of wine too.

New York’s Famous Pizza & Pasta

1000 E 23rd St A – 5, Panama City, FL 32405
Phone: 850-215-5639
Visit Website

Now, if you’re spending time at the Panama City Mall, then you definitely need to stop in at New York’s Famous Pizza and Pasta. After all, going on a shopping spree really can work up quite an appetite, if you ask me. What better way to replenish than with a delicious slice of pizza?

You can get pizza by the slice here at New York’s Famous Pizza & Pasta, or you can really treat yourself by getting a whole pie.

I recommend one of the specialty pies from New York’s Famous Pizza & Pasta. My favorite is the Philly pizza.

Pizza Amore

1405 15th St E, Panama City, FL 32401
Phone: 850-640-3730
Visit Website

Right across the street from the Panama Plaza shopping mall on 15th Street is Pizza Amore, one of the best pizzerias in Panama City, hands down. It’s totally ideal for anyone doing some shopping nearby.

They serve both New York-style pizza and Sicilian-style pizza here at Pizza Amore, so it can be pretty tough to choose sometimes.

I recommend the stuffed pizza if you’re looking for something a bit different. It’s got double the delicious crust and it’s stuffed full of basically two pizzas’ worth of toppings. This is the perfect pizza to share with a large group of friends.

Ramon’s Pizza

4100 US-98, Panama City, FL 32401
Phone: 850-215-5477
Visit Website

Finally, we come to Ramon’s Pizza. Ramon’s may have come last on this list, but that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t check them out first when you want incredibly tasty pizza.

Ramon’s is pretty easy to spot, just look for the brightly-colored red and blue building covered in stars off of West 18th Street.

When you get to Ramon’s, I think you should order either a margarita or a white pizza from their specialty pizza menu, but if you want a classic cheese or pepperoni pizza, then they’ve got you covered there as well. You can also get one of their supreme pizzas if you’re feeling extra-adventurous.

Final Thoughts

As you can see, Panama City knows pizza. The next time you’re looking for a slice of pizza or maybe a whole pie to share with your family or friends, then you’re going to want to take a look at this guide to help you figure out where to order from.

Also, check out our list of restaurants in Panama City if you’re looking for an amazing dining experience.

Did we leave a pizzeria out of this list? Make sure you leave us a comment and we’ll check it out!

This page may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we'll earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Written by Rocco Smith

Rocco is a recent graduate of Florida State University with a Bachelor’s in Editing, Writing, and Media. With seven years’ experience in the restaurant industry as a cook, server, bartender, and more, he is deeply passionate about intertwining his fondness for food with his love of language.