Fishtown is a neighborhood in Philadelphia, PA known for all the exciting things to do. As the city’s center for food, art, and music, it’s no surprise that people spend time in this part of town. Though this neighborhood has a wide array of cuisine to try, we can all probably agree that nothing quite hits the spot like some pizza after a long day or week. With so many pizza joints, though, how will you ever know where to go? Not to worry, we’ve put together a list of pizzerias you have taste to believe.
Whether you’re looking to grab a quick slice, sit down with friends or family, or have a whole pizza to yourself, Fishtown is bound to have a great spot to do all of it. From simple pies to extravagant creations, there’s plenty of pizza to try. Keep reading to learn a bit about each spot!
Best Pizza Restaurants in Fishtown
- Pizzeria Beddia
- PIZZA Shackamaxon
- Fishtown Pizza
- Pizza Brain
- Tommy’s Pizza
- Vince’s Pizzeria Fishtown
- Central Pizza
- Peace A Pie Fishtown
- Wm. Mulherin’s Sons
- Spuntino Wood Fired Pizza
1313 N Lee St, Philadelphia, PA 19125
Phone: (267) 928-2256
If you’re looking for a simple and straightforward pizza restaurant, check out Pizzeria Beddia. This local spot is quite popular with over 700 reviews from customers. many even say this is their favorite pizza in town.
Pizzeria Beddia offers a modest pizza menu with limited but delicious options. We recommend the #2, #5, or #1 if you like a classic pizza. You can even add toppings to the #1 if you’d like. Be sure to grab some soft serve on your way out!
115 E Girard Ave #3907, Philadelphia, PA 19125
Another great restaurant for the pizza purist is PIZZA Shackamaxon. With plenty of glowing reviews, it’s no surprise that this spot is such a popular one. Reviewers say this is their go-to pizza spot in town.
Though this restaurant only takes in-person orders, many locals say it’s well worth the wait, so don’t let that discourage you. PIZZA Shackamaxon offers four pizzas: plain, pepperoni, tomato pie, or their weekly special. Choose between individual slices or a whole pie!
607 E Girard Ave #3408, Philadelphia, PA 19125
Phone: (215) 425-3367
If you’re looking for a pizza spot with a more expansive menu, head over to Fishtown Pizza. This local restaurant serves pizza, of course, as well as other Italian classics, so it’s great for everyone. With plenty fo reviews praising the amazing service and fast delivery, this is a spot you won’t want to miss.
Fishtown Pizza offers a menu with everything from hot dogs and quesadillas to strombolis and pizza, so if you can’t make up your mind, this is a great place to get a bit of everything. Try out the Greek pizza, fiesta pizza, or Nick’s gourmet pizza!
2313 Frankford Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19125, United States
Phone: (215) 291-2965
Looking to be a little bit adventurous? Check out Pizza Brain. This local restaurant is different from your typical pizzeria with pizza-inspired decorations and unique flavors. Serving slices and whole pies, this is the perfect stop no matter how hungry you are.
With so many delicious options to choose from, you may have a hard time making up your mind. We recommend the queenie delouche, felix hupert, or forbes waggensense. Or, order the jane pizza and add your own toppings to customize it!
465 E Girard Ave #3305, Philadelphia, PA 19125
Phone: (215) 634-7552
If you’re looking for a spot to grab a quick slice, check out Tommy’s Pizza. This spot is a popular restaurant among locals and some even say they’ve been coming back to Tommy’s for years on end.
Tommy’s Pizza offers a wide variety of dishes from calzones to quesadillas to pizzas, of course. Be sure to try the Greek white pizza, breakfast pizza, or eggplant parm pizza. Don’t forget to grab some dessert as well!
Vince’s Pizzeria Fishtown
2550 Grant Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19114
Phone: (215) 464-8998
With over 600 reviews on Google, it’s pretty clear that Vince’s Pizzeria Fishtown is a popular spot to grab some pizza. Locals love the thin and crispy crust that the pizza is on as well as its upside-down construction.
Vince’s Pizzeria offers a menu that is pretty customizable with regular and specialty toppings to choose from. Try out the white spinach pizza or make your own creation from the toppings they offer to customize it to your taste!
335 E Girard Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19125
Phone: (215) 426-8036
If you’re looking to try something new, swing by Central Pizza. This local restaurant serves Greek-style pizza as well as a few other dishes. Reviewers especially love the friendly service and delicious food at this spot.
Central Pizza has a wide array of dishes to choose from including pizza. Choose between thin and regular crust on your pizza based on your preference. We recommend the spinach pizza, prosciutto pizza, or pineapple pizza. Be sure to grab some ice cream or cheesecake for dessert!
Peace A Pie Fishtown
1429 Marlborough St, Philadelphia, PA 19125
Phone: (215) 425-4387
Hoping to find a pizza spot with options for everyone? Try out Peace A Pie. This local pizza restaurant offers unique dishes as well as a few options for vegan and gluten-free individuals. This spot offers few tables outside, so we recommend visiting for takeout instead.
Peace A Pie offers pizzas, salads, paninis, and more. Be sure to try the pooky pie, fig & gorgonzola, or truffled mushroom pizzas. Don’t forget to grab some dessert or a treat for your dog on the way out!
Wm. Mulherin’s Sons
1355 N Front St, Philadelphia, PA 19122
Phone: (215) 291-1355
If you’re looking for more of a sit-down, fancy atmosphere, we recommend stopping by Wm. Mulherin’s Sons. This local Italian restaurant was once a whiskey distillery, but now offers delicious food in the Fishtown area.
Wm Mulherin’s Sons serves a seasonal menu, so you’ll be able to try something new each time you visit. Try out the spicy jawn, n’dude yo, or frank white. Don’t forget to sip on a cocktail, beer, or some wine while you eat!
Spuntino Wood Fired Pizza
701 N 2nd St, Philadelphia, PA 19123
Phone: (267) 930-8486
Completing our list of pizza is Spuntino Wood Fired Pizzeria. This local restaurant serves Neapolitan pizza cooked in a wood-fired oven. With numerous great reviews and a BYOB policy, it’s no wonder this is a popular spot.
Spuntino’s offers a great selection of pizzas to choose from, so if you’re having a hard time picking just one, we recommend the valdostana, spinaci, or salsiccia. Be sure to bring your favorite bottle of wine as well!
Nothing beats pizza, that’s for sure. And it definitely seems like nothing beats pizza in this Philly neighborhood. With so many spots to choose from, you may even have to visit all of the pizzerias on our list.
Which pizza are you the most excited about? Let us know! Did we leave a restaurant out of this list? Make sure you leave us a comment and we’ll check it out!
This page may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we'll earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.